The Mystery of the Tolling Bell - A Book By Any Other Name, No. 1

Okay, so this post will start a series of posts (not in any particular order, mind you) of books that I read, which share the same title.  Over the course of collecting books for as many years as I have, I've discovered that there are a number of titles that seem to be reused, particularly when it comes to children's mystery series.  Off the top of my head, I can think of 20 or so titles that were used in multiple series (sometimes just two different series, but there are instances where three or more series used the same title).  So, I figured if I were going to read one book with a title, I'd go ahead and read the sister book as well, then compare them to see if the stories bear any similarities.  I'm hoping this turns out to be a fun adventure, so we shall see...

The Mystery of the Tolling Bell is likely instantly recognizable by Nancy Drew fans as the 23rd mystery in the "Nancy Drew Mystery Stories" series.  Heck, if you do a search online for just the title, you will get page after page of results showing the Nancy Drew book.  What you may not realize, though, is that there is another children's mystery book by the same title.  In the 1960s, a book with this title was published by Christian Literature Crusade with permission by Pickering & Inglis, Ltd. (and for those who read this blog, you may remember I reviewed another book from the P&I publishing company, The Crooked Signpost).  I happened across this book in a local used bookstore, where it had been placed with the Nancy Drew books, likely because without a dust jacket, the book has yellow boards and would seem to the casual eye to be the Nancy Drew book of the same name.  Of course, my eye caught the name of the author and realized immediately it was not Nancy Drew - so my search began to find the book in its brightly colored dust jacket, which I eventually found on eBay.

This book is written by Ellen Jane MacLeod, who wrote more than several children's mysteries, all of which have a Christian theme to them.  Some of the titles, such as The Ski Lodge Mystery, Mystery Gorge, and The Vanishing Light, all sound rather intriguing just by the title alone.  There are several mentions online that Ms. MacLeod also wrote under the pseudonym of "Ella Anderson," which, if there is true, means she also wrote The Crooked Signpost which I read a few months back.  Based on the writing style of the two books, I could easily believe her to be the author of both.

This version of The Mystery of the Tolling Bell features three young men - Paul Maxwell, Phil Leighton, and Pat Riley (funny how all those names begin with "P") - who are returning from a weekend of camping on their own when they are forced to take shelter in an abandoned cottage overlooking a cliff during a torrential rainstorm.  One of them recalls an old story that has circulated through town about the cottage, and how is poses a danger to anyone who approaches it and hears the tolling of a bell in the distance.  Well, as fate would have it, they begin to hear the tolling of a bell - which leaves them ready to run home, despite the raging storm!  They manage to wait out the storm until the morning, and upon returning home, they find another mystery that pulls their attention - a dog named Prince has been stolen from on of their town's wealthy residents, and the boys decide they are going to find it for the reward.  The search for the missing dog and the boys' desire to help a local young outsider become the focus of the book until near the end, when the boys (along with the outsider) make another trip to the abandoned cottage, where they not only learn the secret of the tolling bell, but they come face-to-face with some dastardly criminals who are using the bell and the folk tale to scare people away from the cottage, which they have been using for their base of operations.

It is odd that the tolling bell only plays a small part at the beginning, and then in the climax of the book, and is otherwise ignored throughout the rest of the story.  The main focus seems to be more on the boys' attempts to help young Ben Anderson and his friend, Leo Alexander.  MacLeod uses the story as an opportunity to share the message of the Gospel, as the boys share their Christian faith with Ben and Leo, invite them to church, and encourage them to accept Christ as their own Savior.  The events at the end of the book are what lead to both boys putting their faith in Christ, and the book ends on a very happy note for everyone involved (well, maybe not so much for the four criminals, who are ultimately arrested and thrown in jail!).  While The Crooked Signpost had elements of Christianity woven into the story, this book relies much more heavily on the boys' faith and their attempts to share their faith with Ben and Leo.

 

Since this book is copyrighted 1960 by Pickering & Inglis, it was not published until 14 years after the Nancy Drew story, The Mystery of the Tolling Bell.   That book was written by Mildred Wirt, based on an outline by Harriet Stratemeyer Adams.  In the Nancy Drew version, Nancy and her friends (three girls instead of three boys) travel to Candleton to solve a mystery involving a client of Mr. Drew's, who has been swindled for a lot money.  Turns out others in the coastal town have also been swindled by a woman and man claiming to be selling stock in a successful cosmetic company. While there, Nancy also tries to solve the mystery involving a tolling bell that is hear every time a cave is flooded with water, where a ghostly apparition appears, scaring people away.  While there are definite differences between the books, there are some surprising similarities - (1) both stories have three protagonists; (2) both books deal with an empty cottage overlooking a cliff; (3) both mysteries deal with thieves who are using the cottage as their base of operations; (4) both stories feature a hidden room beneath the cottage; (5) book books obviously deal with a tolling bell that is not easily seen by the hearers; (6) both mysteries feature an urban legend / folk tale that keep people away from the area; and (7) both stories appear to be set somewhere along the New England coast.  Since the Nancy Drew book was published over a decade before MacLeod's book, if there were any "lifting" of ideas or plot elements, it would have been MacLeod from Wirt's mystery.  Certainly, it could just be a complete coincidence, but seriously - how many coincidences like this do we really see outside of series books?

Overall, both books had their good points, and both stories had their drawbacks; however, I did rather enjoy both of them for what they were, and it was fun to read them with the idea of comparing the stories / plots.

RATING:  7 loose-leaf albums of stamps out of 10 for taking something as simple as a tolling bell and turning it into two different (yet similar!) mysteries more than ten years apart!