Up Goes the Curtain - a Penny Parrish book

I picked up this book at Atlanta Vintage Books when we went through Atlanta this past summer going up to Kentucky to visit my Dad.  Having done community theater, I have grown rather fond of reading stories about the theater (such as the Mary Perkins, On Stage newspaper strips, the Carol Page theater stories, Terry Carvel's Theater Caravan, and the Backstagers series for young adults).  So, when I saw this cover, I did not hesitate to buy the book.  I have heard the author, Janet Lambert, mentioned in various book groups to which I belong, but I've never actually owned or read any of her books.  I had always assumed her books were simply young adult romance stories, but this book definitely proves me wrong.  This story was clearly based on Lambert's own experiences, both on Broadway as an actress and as an Army wife (both of these elements playing a large part of this story).  And what surprised me even more is that this book, while having a stand-alone story, is actually part of a series - the fourth book in a series of novels about Penny Parrish (with three prior books being published in 1941, 1942, and 1943 respectively, and two more after this book being published in 1947 and 1950).  Knowing this, I'm more than likely going to track down the other books in the series to see how the character evolves over the course of the decade in which the books were published.  (NOTE - Lambert also wrote series about Tippy Parrish, who is Penny's younger sister, as well as other characters, suich as Parri MacDonald, Candy Kane, Dria Meredith, etc.)

 

Up Goes the Curtain actually contains two separate stories, although Lambert does intertwine them a bit. The book opens with Penny excited about her part in an upcoming Broadway play (her background sounds very similar to that of Carol Page - spent a summer in a stock company training, went to New York, and finally lands a part in a play (p. 10), and, just like Carol Page, she makes a vow that not matter what, she will succeed, so she does not have to return home (p. 12)).  But, since the rehearsals do not begin for three weeks, Penny decides to visit her family, who are staying at Fort Knox, Kentucky where her father and brother are stationed, which begins the mystery that surrounds a young woman named Marcia McMain (what is with the alliteration in names?  Penny Parrish?  Marcia McMain?), who is being escorted to Fort Knox by Terry Hayes, a young man that had previously shown an interest in Penny. Penny is somewhat taken aback by Terry's attitude towards her, but it slowly begins to dawn on her that since Terry is serving in the military, perhaps the woman was a job - perhaps he was actually keeping tabs on her because she was a spy!  (What she does not know, but what the reader does learn thanks to a point-of-view switch to Penny's brother and his wife, who are fully aware of the situation, is that the woman is indeed a spy, and it is Terry's job to flush her out in the open!)  Of course, a lot of miscommunications ensue as the family tries to convince Penny to stay out of it, but Penny is determined to prove her theory - and, of course, she ultimately does through a fateful night at a movie theater when she witnesses the exchange of a note between the woman and a young serviceman.  Penny is able to get a hold of that note, and its contents end up giving the Army everything they need to capture the woman and her accomplice, as well as to foil the damage these spies intended to do.

 

The second half of the book features Penny's return to New York with her sister-in-law (whose name just happens to be Carrol), where they stay at the lavish multi-bedroom apartment Carrol had inherited from her family.  A young woman by the name of Letty, whose husband also happens to be in the military and fighting overseas, joins them in the house, keeping Carrol company while Penny begins her rehearsals and eventually opens the show.  And, in yet another similarity with the Carol Page series, Penny ends up having difficulties with a stage manager who seemingly dislikes her, going out of his way to make things difficult for her - but she eventually learns the truth behind his gruff attitude, and the two develop a friendship of sorts.  In addition (like Carol Page), she happens to personally know the big-name actress who is headlining the play, and because of that, the other actors try to get in her good graces - all except one actor, Miltern Wilde (what a name!), who makes every effort to upstage Penny in every scene they share.  Penny's courage grow, however, to the point where she turns the tables on him one night when he purposefully steps on her toe, causing it to bleed, and she steals the scene from him, getting a thunderous ovation (p. 157) that leads to her gaining his respect.

 

The book ends on a rather sad note, with Penny receiving news that a young man she knows was shot down in a plane over Germany, and it is uncertain whether he survived or not.  There is also uncertainty regarding her growing friendship with the stage manager, and no resolution whatsoever about her feelings for Terry Hayes.  Instead, the book ends with Penny putting on her makeup for another performance of the play, sighing to herself, "It doesn't matter about me - the show must go on" (p. 189).  That ending alone is enough to make me want to hunt down the next book in the series to see where Penny goes from here. 

 

While I had a bit of disappointment in the fact that entire book was not focused on the theater, I did rather enjoy that spy/mystery part in the first half of the book.  The second half that did feature the theater - well, I wish we could have gotten an entire book on that, so the reader could get more fleshed out characters and feel more of the drama and tension among the cast.  As it is, we only get touches upon each of the characters, and I, as the reader, do not really know enough about them, nor spend enough time with them, to really care about how they interact with Penny and how she treats them.  I will be curious to see if any of the other books in the series follow Penny's acting career.  Definitely not a bad read, and one that has me curious enough to read more.

 

RATING:  7 large cokes with lots of ice out of 10 for an unexpected combination of war, spies, theater, and drama - like getting two books for the price of one! 

Carol on Broadway a/k/a Carol Goes to Broadway - the Third Carol Page theater story

First, she served as an apprentice at the Stuyvesant Theatre under Miss Marlowe.  Then, she was able to play summer stock at the Richards Village Theatre in Winasser, Maine.  Now, after a year of theater training, Carol Page is ready to head for Broadway - the ultimate goal of all theater actors!  This is the third book in Helen Dore Boylston's series about a young woman whose love of acting and the theater is awakened after participating in a high school play and getting the opportunity to serve an apprenticeship under an experienced actress.  The series has followed Carol, and her two friends, Julia Gregg and Mike Horodinsky, as they have pursued their careers - Carol as a series actress; Julia as a comedic player; and Mike as a director.  Thus far, the series has given a pretty accurate portrayal of theater life, and so I was anxious to see how Carol's attempts to get a part on Broadway would play out.

 

Carol on Broadway (a/k/a Carol Comes to Broadway) opens as Carol is packing, ready to begin her new life in New York City as an aspiring actress.   Carol and Julia already have a room reserved in a "brownstone on a dingy side street west of Eighth Avenue" (p. 20).  It is there we get to meet our new cast of characters, with whom Carol and Julia will share their New York and Broadway adventures!  And these characters are some of the most fun and unique ones to appear in this series to date.  The first is Mrs. Garrentt, who runs the boarding house. Aldred Dean, who was the leading lady at Richards Village Theatre in the previous book, recommended  the place as a "respectable, old-fashioned theatrical boardinghouse" (p. 21).  Mrs. Garrett (and, yes, the first person I pictured is Charlotte Rae from TV's The Facts of Life - in fact, her image pretty much stuck with me during the whole book!) is a real hoot.  When she opens the door to Carol, Julia, and Mrs. Page, Boylston describes her as an "enormous woman dressed in purple filled the doorway like a sequin-embroidered mountain.  Her frizzed hair was dyed a color between red and blond which could only be classified as nasturtium, and in it she wore an artificial red rose" (p. 22).  With this description, my mind pictured a cross between Charlotte Rae's Mrs. Garrett and Audra Lindley's Mrs. Roper, from Three's Company.  She turns out to be a very caring person, who looks after and protects her tenants as if they were her own children.

 

As for the other tenants - Mitzi Katherine Malloy is another aspiring actress who is somewhat shy and who is beholden to the whims of her boyfriend, "who wants her to dress like those girls in the Russian Drama School" (p. 24); Miss Iverson is an aged actress, who is a bit high-strung and a bit jaded; Charlie Anders is a pasty-looking young man who is quite sure of himself, as well as a self-proclaimed ladies' man; and then there is Billy Beaseley, the former clown and current comic, whose sidekick, Herbert, makes the most unexpected appearance on the stairs of the boardinghouse, startling Carol, Julia, and Mrs. Page alike - for you see, Herbert is a skunk!  Thankfully, the girls soon learn his scent glands have been removed, and he has been trained to be a part of Billy's act,  The girls make fast friends with all of the other tenants (well, except maybe Charlie), and Carol especially gains some valuable knowledge from each of them, in their own way.

 

Boylston does not go easy with the girls.  Carol and Julia are both excited as they head out their first day to "make the rounds," as the saying goes.  They hit up every casting agency they can find, only to discover that no one is willing to see an unknown.  It seems that in order to see a casting agent, one must have experience on Broadway; yet, the only way to get experience is to get cast in a play through a casting agent!  The girls are discouraged, but they remain determined. For a while, at least.  Billy ends up providing Carol with some much needed advice, which ultimately gets her in to see one casting agent - Arthur G. Sweetster Theatrical Enterprises.  While he does not get her cast, he does provide some encouragement that eventually leads her to taking a job doing a radio commercial.  Eventually, just as Carol is about to give up hope, she falls into the good fortune of getting a small role in a play at the Valencia Theater - which, by the way, is an actual theater in New York City, located in Queens, New York.  The real Valencia Theater opened its doors in 1929, which means it would have been in existence at the time this book was written and published.

 

One thing I enjoyed about all of the tension that Carol discovers while rehearsing for this play is how realistically it is portrayed.  As a professional Broadway play, rather than just a community theater production, it's less of a family-generating atmosphere where everyone pulls together and more of a dog-eat-dog arena, where everyone is out for themselves and looking to prove they are better and more talented than everyone else.  At one point, as the cast are heading to New Haven (which is about four hours away from New York City) for the opening performance, one of the other cast members makes the snide remark that "it really won't matter how many mistakes you make, really.  After all, just remember you haven't got an important part" (p. 166).  Carol, already frustrated, replies with a stupendously catty remark, "Thanks so much.  I hope you'll be able to get some reset.  That part must be an awful strain on you.  You're looking terribly tired" (p. 166).  The insinuation that the other woman is old and tired looking would certainly strike hard to any actress, and Carol, being the nice person she really is, immediately regrets the comment.  Me, on the other hand, was happy to finally see her strike back a bit!

 

Boylston keeps Carol on a timeline that she has established with her father - if she is not steadily employed as an actress within one year, then she will return home and go to college.  Boylston builds some suspense for the reader, as the production in which Carol has a party is shut down, leaving the poor girl with very little time to find another role before she must return home.  Just as she has given up hope and is packing to leave, she gets a call from none other than Miss Marlowe, who is back at the Stuyvesant and ready to put on a new production written by a friend of Mike Horodinsky.  It is a big chance she is taking, but since the theatre is being converted to one showing films, Miss Marlowe believes she has nothing to lose.  Carol, of course, is cast in a large role opposite Miss Marlowe herself, and on the opening night, Carol is surprised to find her parents and brother were in the audience.  And, as fate would have it, so was Mr. Sweetster, who is so impressed with the play that he is going to have it produced on Broadway!  Thus, Carol finds herself in a guaranteed production just in time to beat that deadline, and it leaves us all wondering - just where will Carol go next?

 

While Carol's good fortune in getting in to see the casting agent, falling into the radio commercial gig, lucking into the role of her first Broadway play, and the instant success of her performance with Miss Marlowe reek of series book coincidences, the one realistic thing about it is that in order to truly make it, it all boils down to who you know.  And in each of these cases, that is exactly how Carol managed to succeed in each circumstance. 

 

There are plenty of other subplots that move the story along - Julia managing to land a role in a touring show; Mike meeting a young woman who is an aspiring playwright and who clearly has eyes for Mike; Mitzi's controlling boyfriend and her efforts to change; and Billy's desire to get back to performing in the circus like he and Herbert used to do.  The art in this book is once again provided by Major Felton, who did the illustrations in the previous book.  They do not really depict any exciting scenes (one is simply Carol pointing theater-goers to their seats, which another simply shows Carol taking bows at the end of a performance); however, they are clean and a little more refined than those in the second book.  Plus, the one illustration depicts the scene where the girls first meet Herbert!  And, just like the first two books, this book was also published in Britain, where it underwent a slight name change - instead of Carol simply being "ON" Broadway, for the British edition, the title tells reader that Carol "COMES TO" Broadway.  It follows the format of the first two books, with that same headshot of Carol, only it is outlined in blue, instead of the yellow of the second book or red of the first book.

 

One final thing worth mentioning is the dedication at the beginning of the book.  Boylston dedicates the book "FOR BUSHY - Who Was No Help at All."  I had to snicker when I read this, as Bushy Trott is the name of a villain from one of the Nancy Drew Books (Old Attic),  and it is also a nickname of a very good friend of mine.  The fact that Bolyston dedicates the book to Bushy with the comment that he was "no help at all" certainly keeps in line with the villainy of the Nancy Drew crook; as far as my friend?  Well, let's just say he would definitely get a kick out of this dedication!

 

RATING:  10 tattered, disreputable tramps on a park bench out of 10 for giving readers a taste for the darker, more difficult side of professional theater work - it's not all glamour and stardom!

Carol Goes Backstage a/k/a Carol Goes on the Stage - the First Carol Page theater story

Having enjoyed some years performing in local community theaters, it is only natural that I would pick up series books having to do with the theater.  I can't recall exactly how I came to find out about the Carol Page theater stories, but once I learned of them, I had to track them down.  I managed to get the first three fairly easy, but it was that fourth and final book in the series that proved elusive (and the completist in me just will not start reading a series until I have all of the books first!).  I did manage to track it down at last, and so I was finally able to sit down and give the series a read.  Of course, this does not account for the fact that the series was published in England, as well as here in the States, and that the book names differed depending on where they were published - so that left me with the conundrum - do I wait until I track down all of the "alternate" titles before I start reading?  Since I'm writing this post, clearly I decided not to wait (and more on those alternate titles below...).

 

Carol Goes Backstage (a/k/a Carol Goes on the Stage) is the first book in the series, introducing readers to seventeen-year old Carol Page, a high school graduate who has gotten a small taste of the theater in her senior year and has decided that acting on the stage is a career she would like to pursue - much to her parents' chagrin!   Carol, and her best friend Julia Gregg, audition for a chance to be a part of an apprentice group "connected with the Stuyvesant Theater in New York" (p. 54), where a select group of aspiring actors had the opportunity to learn under the tutelage of Miss Phyllis Marlowe, a woman Carol calls "a swell actress" (p. 55).  Of course, they are selected, and Carol is barely able to convince her parents to allow here to attend (as her father is determined that acting schools are a waste of time, and she needs to focus on a viable career).  Thus begins the journey of Carol Page to become an actress of the Broadway stage!

 

Carol Page is not like a lot of her contemporaries in series fiction of the time, as her family is not affluent, providing her the freedom to do as she pleases; while the Page family is not poor by any means, she and Julia share a room in a "respectable girls' club" (p. 88), where the room was "sunny and comfortable, and the food, as Julia pointed out, was probably better than anything they could have turned out for themselves" (p. 89).  But that does not stop one particular apprentice - Michael Horodinsky - from viewing Carol as highfalutin and taking an instant disliking to her, which leads to considerable contention between the two throughout the entire book.  Now, having watched soap operas for many years, I've learned that when two individuals begin a relationship by warring with one another, it usually leads to not only an amicable friendship, but eventually a romance - and while there is no romance in this book at all, I have a sneaky suspicion that Carol and Mike have a budding romance somewhere in their future (we shall have to see what the next three books hold in store...).

 

The story approaches theater life in a very realistic way.  While Carol has talent, she gets in her own way sometimes by thinking she knows better than others, or in thinking that she can succeed by copying the way she has seen others perform a particular role on stage.  She is called out more than once and must learn a bit of humility along the way, which often occurs with beginning actors in the theater.  And Julia, who was the one from the very beginning with big dreams of becoming a star, finds her path to stardom changed along the way, as she (and everyone around her) discover that she is far more talented as a comedic actor than in any serious role.  The story also introduces readers to all of the backstage trials and tribulations of putting together a show for the stage - from building of sets, working of the lights, learning of lines, timing of rehearsals, and overcoming differing temperaments of the actors, directors, stage managers, and set designers.  The character of Miss Marlowe reminds me of one particular director I had the pleasure of working with on a number of plays - he was extremely strict, he was direct and to the point, and he did not tolerate those who were not serious about their performance; yet, he would always offer suggestions and encouragement, and his efforts taught all of us so much about acting.  These are the things Carol, Julia, and all of their newfound friends discover during their time at the Stuyvesant Theater.

 

The book does have a few typical series book scenarios in it.  Once incident involves Carol having to hitchhike back to the high school theater after a friend convinces her to go out to the nearby river to run lines just before the show, and then his car dies.  Carol is picked up by a dazzling woman who questions her about her upcoming performance in Miss Hipkin's Descent (not a real play); it is only later when her brother Phil takes her to New York to see a play does Carol learn the woman was an actual Broadway actress, who they have the opportunity to meet backstage and who encourages Carol to pursue a career in acting!  Another situation involves the owner of a summer theater who offers a job each year to one talented apprentice, and so Miss Marlowe's apprentices put together their own show for a chance that one of them might get selected to be that person!  The only problem is, Carol's troublesome aunt has convinced her mother than Carol should be brought home and not allowed to stay in New York.  As such, Carol must find a way to convince her mother the theater is not detrimental to her future, that Michael Horodinsky is not her boyfriend, and that she has a real chance at landing that summer job with the summer program.  Obviously, all goes well and Carol is not only allowed to stay, but she - along with Julia, Michael, and two others - are selected to join the summer stock at Mr. Richards' theater (which leads directly into the second book in this series).

 

Now, since this book does deal with the theater and Broadway, it only stands to reader the author would include real plays and actors in its pages.  Carol and her brother take in a production of Candida, which is a comedy written by George Bernard Shaw, which was performed in both London and New York in the early 1900s.  Mr. Anders, who introduces the apprentices to the Stuyvesant Theater, tells them how the theater used to be an opera house, and how famous actors sushc as Edwin Booth, Sir Henry Irving, Sarah Bernhardt, and "the great Duse" (p. 80) had all acted on that stage.  All of those are real life actors, with the great Duse referring to Eleonora Duse, an Italian actress considered one of the greatest of all time.  In addition, readers are treated to the history of "the green room" (the backstage area were acteors wait until they must go on stage), which, in the book, is said to originate from the early days in England, when the theaters had waiting rooms close to the stage, where the doors were painted green (p. 87).  While the book references those early London theaters as "the Drury Lane and Covent Garden" (p. 87), in real life, it was likely from London's Blackfriars Theatre, in which the waiting room was painted green.  It is these type of historical facts that really breathe additional life and realism into the story!

 

One final tidbit I must mention, which has no connection to theater but which I found to be amusing and quite coincidental, is found on page 59, when Carol is trying to convince her father that she wants to pursue an acting career and go to New York to be an apprentice to Miss Marlowe.  In her argument, she finally confesses to her father, "Daddy - I don't want to go to Wellesley" (p. 59).   This is so amusing because Harriet Stratemeyer Adams, one of the major driving forces behind the highly successful Nancy Drew series, was a graduate of Wellesley (Class of 1914)!  Thus, the story has an unexpected (and unintentional!) series book reference in it.

 

The series is written by Helen Dore Boylston, who also authored the Sue Barton nursing series from 1936 to 1952.  Boylston was a nurse in real life, so her writing stories about a nurse was only natural.  Five years after her first Sue Barton book was published, she began the Carol Page series of novels.  From online sources, Boylston received advice from her neighbor, Eva Le Gallienne (a Broadway actress who eventually left that career and found the Civic Repertory Theatre - on whom the character of Miss Marlowe was clearly based).  Boylston also went backstage at the Civic Repertory Theatre to gain additional research, all of which explains why the details in her first book are so spot-on with regard to theater life!  (On a side note, the Civic Repertory Theatre was once a home for French dramas and operas, leaving one to believe that the theater was the inspiration for Boylston's Stuyvesant in the book.)

 

Now, as indicated above, this book was first published in America in 1941, but later republished in 1943 in England by John Lane The Bodley Head publishers under the title Carol Goes on the Stage.  Both books kept the same headshot of Carol on their covers, and both books featured the same beautiful internal illustrations by Frederick E. Wallace.  They also both featured a brief word of thanks from the author to Jane Ayer Cobb, "with whose help, encouragement, and staying powers have been invaluable throughout the writing of this book."  Cobb was an author of short stories and children's books, and some online sources give her credit as being a "co-author" of the Carol Page series.  An article in The New York Times written after the death of Cobb indicates the Carol Page series was "originated by Mrs. Berry, but again bore only the name of Miss Boylston" (The New York Time - Jane Cobb).  How much truth there is to this statement, I cannot say.

 

What I can say, though, is that I thoroughly enjoyed the book.  The characters were engaging and realistic, the portrayal of life in the theater was entirely accurate and not overly dramatized at all,  and the story itself was perfectly paced and throughout enjoyable.  I am anxiously looking forward to reading book two!

 

RATING:  10  bunches of white peonies out of 10 for a wonderful story of theater life and the start of one young woman's journey to becoming a real actress!