Penny Parker Mystery Stories No. 16 - Swamp Island

And so we come to the penultimate Penny Parker mystery story, as we reach the 16th book in the series.  It is truly amazing to me how far this series has come, and how Mildred Wirt's writing has evolved over the course of the nine years and 17 books that were published in this series.  What started as a more-or-less typical children's mystery series has gradually grown into stories with more intricate plots, more dastardly and dangerous villains, and definitely more adult-oriented stories.  This story definitely ups the ante in all of those aspects.

Swamp Island is a story that leads readers to think the mystery is one thing, but then takes it in an entirely different direction.  Wirt opens the mystery with Penny and her best friend, Louise, sailing a flat-bottomed skiff through a local swamp to collect flowers for a banquet that her father is putting together (p. 1).  Now, right off the bat, this raises a few questions, the main one being just where in the world if Riverview?  Previous books indicated the town is only a few hours from a beach (see Voice from the Cave).  Yet, now, here the girls are making their way through swamp land to collect flowers, such as Cherokee roses, water lilies, yellow jessamine, and iris (p. 3).  A quick internet search reveals that these flowers are native to the southeastern areas of the United States; so, does that mean Riverview is located in the south (such as Florida)?  Other tidbits from the books would be more indicative of a mid-western setting, such as those clues to River Heights in the Nancy Drew books.  I suppose that is something we will never know.

Regardless, Penny stays true to nature (no pun intended), as her father had given her $20 to purchase flowers for the banquet (p. 3), which is equivalent to $350 in today's money; yet, she decides to pocket the money and gather swamp blossoms instead.  While in the swamp, the girls come face-to-face with some rather not-so-nice gun-carrying men who warn the girls away - forcing them to leave Louise's dog, Bones, behind (p. 8)!  I wonder when Louise got the dog, as she never mentioned having a dog in any prior book.  The girls learn the men are Ezekiel Hawkins and his two sons, Hod and Coon (p. 13).  You have to give Wirt credit for using some rather unusual names.  Ezekiel and Hod are both Biblical names, but Coon is an odd choice, considering its negative connotation (although, back in Wirt's day when this book was published, the word may have been more connected with hunting and working dogs).  And Ezekiel's wife's name is actually Manthy (p. 14)!  By the end of this second chapter, we get a hint at what we think will be the mystery - a radio warning to be on the lookout for escaped convict Danny Deevers, alias Spike Devons (p. 15).  It is interesting to note that "Danny Deevers" is the name of an 1890 poem by Rudyard Kipling, considered by many to be one of Kipling's most significant early works, which tells the story of the execution of a British soldier in India for murder.

We quickly learn that Danny Deevers was sent to prison because of some stories Jerry Livingston wrote about shortages at the Third Federal Loan Bank in Riverview (p. 17), and so readers have the expectation that the story is going to center around Deevers and his desire for revenge on the man who put him away - similar to the story of the original Cape Fear film from 1962.  But, if that is your belief, well, you'd be sadly mistaken.  Other than one incident where Jerry is knocked unconscious (p. 46), Jerry plays little part in the mystery, and as a result, so does Danny Deevers.  Instead, Penny's focus is on finding out exactly what the Hawkins men are up to in that swamp (and although she believes it is somehow connected to Danny Deevers, there are incidents that occur - such as a stolen shotgun, a last-minute save from a charging boar, and missing food - that are misdirects and red herrings that are ultimately revealed to be completely unrelated to Deevers).  While the book and overall mystery are good, the false start ended up with a bit of a let-down by the end of the story.

As usual, Wirt throws some things into the story that have real life connections.  For instance, more than once in the story there are references to Neco cigarettes - described as "one of the strongest cigarettes on the market" (p. 47).  As it turns out, NECCO was a candy company back in the day that sold chalky white candy cigarettes back in the '20s and '30s, so one might assume that Wirt perhaps had some of those as a child and perhaps integrated them into her story as a cute nod to them.  There is also the hotel where Penny's father is throwing the banquet - Hillcrest Hotel (p.21).  Back in the day, there was a hotel by that name in Toledo, Ohio, where it is said authors, artists, and business people would regularly stay (including Amelia Earhart, who stayed there in 1933).  In addition, an accident that provides Salt and Penny with an important clue occurs at the intersection of Jefferson and Huron (p. 30) - and, wouldn't you know it, but there is such an intersection in downtown Toledo, Ohio, just blocks away from the Maumee River!

And we certainly must not forget Black Island, a remote island in the middle of the swamp, which holds secrets that Penny is determined to uncover.  Now, the name of this island has several possibilities when it comes to references outside of the story.  First, the name is also the title to the seventh volume in The Adventures of Rin Tintin, a comic series by Herge (The Black Island).  It was first published in black and white in 1938, and later republished in color in 1943, just four years prior to this book being published.  Black's Island is also the name of an island off the gulf coast in Florida, which was so named after the pirate, Black Sam Bellamy, who made the island his home back in the 1700s (and in case you're interested, this particular 7-acre island is currently for sale for just $50 million!).  Also, there is another Black Island, located at the center of Muscongus Bay (in Maine).  This 15-acre island was settled by Europeans back in the early 1800s, and at the start of the 1900s, approximately 50 people lives on the island.  No doubt, there are other Black Islands out there in the world, so it leaves one to wonder which one inspired Wirt for this book!

K.S. Woerner provides the art for both the cover and the frontis piece, and I have to say, neither of them are his best work.  His art from the earlier books is definitely superior to the art in this one.  One thing I did note, however, is that in the early books of the series, Penny is depicted by Woerner with a bow in her hair on most of the illustrations; however, Penny lacks the bow in both the cover and the internal of this book, and her hair is more modern, curled style.  One wonders if he was instructed to give Penny an older appearance, and so the bow was done away with, or was it simply a matter of changing hair styles for young women from 1939 to 1947 that prompted the change.

Again, the story was not bad at all - definitely more mature storylines than in the earlier books; but, I was disappointed by the hinted mystery surrounding Danny Deevers at the beginning of the book that was never truly the main mystery of the book.  I was looking forward to the Cape Fear-style tale of a convict looking for revenge on the man who put him away, but instead got a story about bootleggers hiding in the swamp.  Well, with only one more book left in the series, I'm looking forward to see how Wirt ends her tales of Penny Parker's adventures!

RATING:  8 large puts of turtle stew out of 10 for sending Penny into more dangerous situations, while deepening the relationship between her and Jerry Livingston!