Harlequin Gothic Romance Series No. 32015 - Island of Mystery

"It was the perfect summer job, or so she thought - until it became a nightmare of danger and intrigue" (cover blurb) 

 

The fifteenth Harlequin Gothic Romance was written by yet another new author to the line:  Margaret M. Scariano.  Ms. Scariano (1924-2013) was the author's actual name, and she was a graduate of Fresno State who went on get a master's in English from Illinois State University.  She was not exactly a prolific writer, having only 18 books published; however, her works were of a wide variety, including stories for lower reading levels, young adult fiction and non-fiction, adult stories, and this book - her one and only contribution to the Gothic genre.  Based on this story, it is rather surprising Scariano did not write more Gothics, as she definitely has the talent for it, capturing the right mix of mystery, suspense, and romance.

 

Island of Mystery is the story of a young woman hired to help organize a wealthy family's papers to help put together a family history, and in order to do this, she must travel to an isolated island and stay in a rather foreboding house with family members who do not necessarily want her there!  If this plot sounds familiar, perhaps that is because it is a nearly identical plot to Tree of Evil, which book I just read and reviewed just two weeks ago.  I have no doubt there are plenty of Gothic novels from his era with similar plots (considering the plethora of books pushed on the market at the time, there would have to be!), but I do find it rather amusing that by pure chance I would read two books so similar this close to each other.  I mean, the opening sequence with the young protagonist on a boat, traversing rough waters to get to the island is almost identical to that of Roberta Morrison's Tree of Evil.  Both stories also feature a family member who dies from falling off a cliff, and both stories feature a locked room from which sounds can be heard (when there is not supposed to be anyone in there), as well as some secret that is held within the family papers that someone is willing to kill for. And if that were not enough, but stories have natives (Hawaiians in the Tree of Evil, and Native Americans in this one) who play an important part of the tale.  Thankfully, though Scariano eventually diverges and provides some variations that gives this Gothic some distinction from the other.

 

In Island of Mystery, Jenny Fletcher (a relation of Jessica Fletcher, perhaps?) is a grad student who goes go Lone Lake Lodge in order to help Grace Hamilton put her family papers in order so that they can be donated to the Montana Historical Society (the author likely chose Montana as the setting, since she was originally from that state and began her college career there).  From the moment of her arrival, however, there is unrest with the family.  Grace resides on the island with her two nephews - Glenn and Martin Larabie, whose mother was Grace's sister.  She took them in after their father left and their mother died in a tragic boat accident.  The brothers are at odds, however, on what Grace should do with the island when she dies, and poor Jenny gets caught in the middle.  Bobby Black Bear, the Native American who also resides on the island, warns her not to take sides, as it will not end well for her.  Jenny also learns that Grace has had previous secretaries, none of whom lasted very long.  Jenny is determined to prove them wrong, as she plans to use the Hamilton family history as a part of her thesis for grad school.  She just never realized the tension she was going to face in the great house.  To round out the oddball cast, there is Lone Willow, the companion to Grace, a young Native American who is going to college via correspondence courses (yes, this definitely shows the age of the book!), and who the family affectionately refers to as "Ruthie."  There is also Mr. Alger, the rather rough-around-the-edges cook who makes it clear in no uncertain terms that he knows the real reason Jenny is there and does not want her there.  

 

The mystery comes into play when Grace and Jenny come across an old lease that reveals the island was only leased to her family, and neither she, nor the boys, own the property.  Jenny is certain they will come across a later document that eventually transferred title, but Grace is unsure.  When Grace finds the diary of Glenn and Martin's mother, she learns a dark secret that could have very serious repercussions on the entire family, particularly with regard to who really owns the island!  Unfortunately, before she can reveal the truth, she is murdered, and the diary goes missing.  Jenny soon finds her life is in danger, as someone thinks she knows what was in that diary, and they are determined to keep her from revealing it!  The suspense really plays out in the final act of the story, and in true Gothic fashion, everyone's secrets are revealed at last, and Jenny (along with the reader) learns that not everyone is who they say they are!

 

The cover artist is not identified, but the art is beautifully rendered.  The scene is actually a mixture of several scenes - one scene, where Jenny is pushed down the stairs when exploring the fourth floor ballroom, and another scene where Jenny has found the diary on a stormy night.  The only thing I noticed about the art (and it's rather nit picky, I know) is that while Jenny's hair appears to be blowing from the wind, the wick of the burning candle does not appear to be affected at all by that same wind.  (And since that particular scene of Jenny occurs while she is in a room with a broken window, it would only make sense that the wind from the storm outside was blowing in, affecting both her hair and the candle.)  This is probably one of my favorite covers from this series - that half turn, the storm outside, the hands reaching out for her. It breaks the mold of the stereotypical "girl running away from the house in the background" standard scene and instead gives us a tension-filled moment where we can almost feel Jenny's fear as she is about to be pushed.

 

One thing I did want to mention was the author's choice of names for the cook.  Mr. "Alger" made me immediately think of Horatio Alger (1832-1899), who was a very prolific author of young adult novels in the second half of the 19th century.  Most of his stories are referred to as "rags to riches" tales about young lads in poverty who rise above their circumstances to make good for themselves.  Interestingly enough, one of Alger's pseudonyms was Arthur "Hamilton," which also happens to be Grace's last name in this book.  It could be pure coincidence - or, just perhaps, Scariano was actually paying a slight homage to a fellow author, albeit one a bit before her time.

 

RATING: 9 rugged mountain sheep out of 10 for spinning a slightly new take on an already established Gothic plot - and throwing in a few surprises along the way.