The continuing story of the Collins family has been kept alive by Big Finish Productions in these audio stories, and my love for the show, its stories, and its characters has waited impatiently for each new story to come long. While I have not exactly enjoyed the latest offerings (where they put three or four short stories together on each audio), they finally got it right with the 13-part episodic tale, Bloodline, which picks up where the last mulit-part story, Bloodlust, left off - David Collins and Amy Jennings preparing for their wedding!
Now, before we begin, I do have to say that the first few episodes are a big jumbled - at least to me. There are a number of new characters, new voices, and it gets a bit difficult to tell them apart and figure out who is who and what is going on. I'm not sure if this is because the episodes are written by different people, which obviously creates a different feel for each episode, or if it's because there are a number of actors involved who are not from the original Dark Shadows cast, and so it takes a bit of getting used to in order to differentiate their voices. Whatever the reason, once you get through the first three or so episodes, the story really starts to pick up the pace, the actors get into their groove, and it really begins to feel like Dark Shadows once again...
The story begins with David and Amy preparing for their wedding. But, as we all know, things are not going to go exactly as planned. Someone is out to ensure that Amy and David never get married. Barnabas returns to Collinsport, with Dr. Julia Hoffman in tow! Of course, Grayson Hall passed away years ago, so actress Julie Newmar (yes, THAT Julie Newmar) steps into the role, and those who listened to "The Curse of Shurafa" audio story will recall that Julia was transferred into another body - and Julie Newmar provides the voice of that new body! It's a great way to bring back such a wonderful character (just as they did with Barnabas), and Newmar definitely provides listeners with the feel of Dr. Hoffman.
The first half of the story provides the build-up (including a hospital explosion that cuts of Barnabas' blood supply and results in the death of Cody's father), and while there are some subtle hints of things to come, it isn't until the second volume of Bloodline that things really hit full force! Just as the wedding begins, David disappears - and no one at the wedding even remembers him! Why was Amy wearing a wedding gown? Why was everyone there? And who in the world is David Collins? It turns out that David was thrown into the past - back to when his ancestor, Quentin Collins, was about to be born. But what happens when Quentin's mother suddenly falls in love with David - will he inadvertently change time?
It turns out, though, that David is not the only one who disappears and is forgotten. One by one, members and friends of the Collins family begin to disappear. Harry Cunningham is thrown back in time...as is Jacqueline Tate...and Lela Collins...and Cyrus Longworth-Jennings...and Vivian Bell...and Quentin Collins and Amy Jennings...and others! Each is thrust into a different time, where they have to be careful to avoid entanglement with the people of that time so as to not alter the timeline and destroy their own future! But what happens when Jacqueline is accused of murder and put on trial? And Cyrus is haunted by the ghost of Jenny Collins? And poor Harry, who finds himself in the hospital being treated by none other than Cody's father? And Lela faces off against the misguided and vile Reverend Trask, who is hell-bent on condemning Victoria Winters as a witch? And Quentin and Amy find themselves in the near past, where Amy has the opportunity to protect her son from harm?
Time travel was a big staple in the original series, so it fits in nicely that the writers use multiple levels of time travel in this story to create a huge central tale of vengeance on the Collins family. It is also fun to see the return of Rosier, who first hides within Cody, offering him his heart's desire - but who is ultimately taken by Amy, who uses Rosier to try and put an end to all of the turmoil taking place at Collinwood. But, it is ultimately Barnabas' own bloodlust that brings everything to a crashing resolution, as he not only feeds on Cody, but also brutually attacks, feeds on, and kills a young couple in Collinsport! It is this feeding frenzy and Dr. Hoffman's desire to protect and help Barnabas that leads to the big revelation of who has been doing all of this....
I'm certainly not going to spoil the big reveal - as it definitely ties in to a previous audio story; however, I will say that Big Finish give fans a HUGE payoff with this story by providing listeners and fans with something we never thought we'd see (or rather, hear!) again - the voices of Joan Bennett, Thayer David, Jonathan Frid, Grayson Hall, and Dennis Patrick!!!! I can't even begin to tell you the giddiness that came over me as I heard their voices in the story. Now, I'm not about to spoil anything by explaining how they play into the story, but I will say this - some are flashbacks in the past, while others are actually in the current story! So, if you are a fan of the original series, this is the one audio drama that you cannot miss!
I understand that the producers have to introduce new characters to slowly take the place of the actors who are either getting too old to continue or who have passed on - so that the Dark Shadows legacy can continue in the years to come - but I do wish that more of the original cast had been used in this - Kathryn Leigh Scott was barely used at all, as was Lara Parker. David Selby and Nancy Barrett probably saw the most screen time, which wasn't really all that much, with Marie Wallace and Christopher Pennock coming in a close second. I still have more of the anthology audios to listen to, so hopefully the original cast will show up in more of those.
In any event, Bloodline was a successful continuation of the Dark Shadows saga, and I can't wait to see what Big Finish has in store for fans next!
RATING: 8 time-surviving tape recorders out of 10 for keeping these characters and stories alive with a true Dark Shadows feel for fans like me!
Review of books that I have read - my own personal thoughts and opinions of the book, its plot, the author, and everything else.
Saturday, November 30, 2019
Monday, November 25, 2019
Hardy Boys Adventures, Book 19 - Dungeons & Detectives
I really hate the fact that the Hardy Boys books are better written than the Nancy Drew books these days. I've always been more of a Nancy Drew fan, simply because the Nancy Drew books were more focused on mystery, while it seemed the Hardy Boys books were more about adventure. And even though this new incarnation of the detective brothers is called "Hardy Boys Adventures," the stories are definitely more about the mystery, and the ghostwriters clearly put more time and effort into the plotting and execution than the writers of the Nancy Drew stories.
The latest HBA book, Dungeons & Detectives, is a prime example of what makes this series a step above the current Nancy Drew books. First, it is not about sabotage. While in recent years, the Nancy Drew books seem to all be stories about sabotage, the Hardy Boys books have offered up various mystery tropes - hidden treasures, kidnapped and/or missing people, revenge, hauntings, etc. This latest book (which, surprisingly, has over 200 pages! the first Hardy Boys Adventures book to offer such a high page count!) features the brothers hunting down a stolen comic book, all the while dealing with a comic store owner and comic book fans who all have secrets. Throw in an old castle with a moat and hidden rooms, a Halloween costume party that offers up a myriad of ways for a crook to commit a crime, and a nosy high school reporter who is determined to solve this case before the Hardy Boys do, and you've got the perfect trappings for an exciting story!
Something that does surprise me about this book is how many pop culture references are in the book. There are mentions of the actual Dungeons & Dragons game, the latest issue of Detective comics, Black Panther, Wonder Woman, Chewbacca, Wolverine, Bruce Wayne, James Bond, and even Captain Kirk from Star Trek. Frank even dresses up like Sherlock Holmes at one point! I have to say, though, that the top-notch, best pop cultural references goes to pages 106-07, when Frank and Joe meet the intrepid high school reporter, Charlene, in costume:
As for the mystery itself, the brothers must help their local comic book dealer locate a stolen comic book that could potentially be worth tens of thousands of dollars. Sabers & Serpents #1 was a comic created by the dealer's father and his partner back in the day, and it was based upon a role-playing game the two had created. Unfortunately, circumstances led to not only the partnership dissolving, but nearly all of the first issues of the comic being destroyed in a fire! It seems that rare first issue had a map to a treasure, but the partner, Filmore, had torn out the page that contained the map from every comic - well, at least from every issue except the one owned by the comic dealer! Frank and Joe have to wonder if it was stolen by someone who knew about the treasure map and was determined to find that treasure in the old Scottish castle.
The hunt is on, and honestly, reading about the Halloween party at the old castle, the boys going through the hidden tunnels, finding captives in a dungeon, facing off against a knight in armor with a deadly ax to grind, and chasing after a ghostly menace who is determined to get to the gold - it reminded me of the 1970s' television episodes, "The Hardy Boys and Nancy Drew Meet Dracula," where the three attend a Halloween party at an old castle and make their way through the catacombs in search of a solution to their mystery.
Overall, the story was a lot of fun (especially for a comic book geek like me!) and the mystery was well-plotted. Even I was surprised by the identity of the culprit behind everything. Now to wait for the next book, when the boys return to Black Bear Mountain (the site of a previous mystery in this series)!
RATING: 10 lifeless bodies falling from the rafters out of 10 for proving beyond a shadow of a doubt that the Hardy Boys and Nancy Drew can still provide fantastic mysteries for kids today!
The latest HBA book, Dungeons & Detectives, is a prime example of what makes this series a step above the current Nancy Drew books. First, it is not about sabotage. While in recent years, the Nancy Drew books seem to all be stories about sabotage, the Hardy Boys books have offered up various mystery tropes - hidden treasures, kidnapped and/or missing people, revenge, hauntings, etc. This latest book (which, surprisingly, has over 200 pages! the first Hardy Boys Adventures book to offer such a high page count!) features the brothers hunting down a stolen comic book, all the while dealing with a comic store owner and comic book fans who all have secrets. Throw in an old castle with a moat and hidden rooms, a Halloween costume party that offers up a myriad of ways for a crook to commit a crime, and a nosy high school reporter who is determined to solve this case before the Hardy Boys do, and you've got the perfect trappings for an exciting story!
Something that does surprise me about this book is how many pop culture references are in the book. There are mentions of the actual Dungeons & Dragons game, the latest issue of Detective comics, Black Panther, Wonder Woman, Chewbacca, Wolverine, Bruce Wayne, James Bond, and even Captain Kirk from Star Trek. Frank even dresses up like Sherlock Holmes at one point! I have to say, though, that the top-notch, best pop cultural references goes to pages 106-07, when Frank and Joe meet the intrepid high school reporter, Charlene, in costume:
Her costume rang a bell, but I couldn't quite place it until I saw the HELLO MY NAME IS ... sticker she was wearing with the name Nancy written beneath it.
"Nancy Drew!" I said. Nancy was another real-life teen detective, and her master sleuthing had made national headlines a few times. We'd actually teamed up with her to solve a big case last Christmas and became friends--well, I mean, after she got over thinking we were suspects!It was nice to see a nod to A Nancy Drew Christmas, the Nancy Drew Diaries special edition that was published last year, which featured the Hardy Boys. This type of reference hearkens back to the olden days when the Nancy Drew and Hardy Boys books would reference previous mysteries that the teen detectives had solved. Considering the length of this book and the reference, it makes me wonder if perhaps this mystery was originally intended to be a "special edition" for the Hardy Boys (considering the typical Hardy Boys book is about half the length of this one). In any event, the reference was great to read!
As for the mystery itself, the brothers must help their local comic book dealer locate a stolen comic book that could potentially be worth tens of thousands of dollars. Sabers & Serpents #1 was a comic created by the dealer's father and his partner back in the day, and it was based upon a role-playing game the two had created. Unfortunately, circumstances led to not only the partnership dissolving, but nearly all of the first issues of the comic being destroyed in a fire! It seems that rare first issue had a map to a treasure, but the partner, Filmore, had torn out the page that contained the map from every comic - well, at least from every issue except the one owned by the comic dealer! Frank and Joe have to wonder if it was stolen by someone who knew about the treasure map and was determined to find that treasure in the old Scottish castle.
The hunt is on, and honestly, reading about the Halloween party at the old castle, the boys going through the hidden tunnels, finding captives in a dungeon, facing off against a knight in armor with a deadly ax to grind, and chasing after a ghostly menace who is determined to get to the gold - it reminded me of the 1970s' television episodes, "The Hardy Boys and Nancy Drew Meet Dracula," where the three attend a Halloween party at an old castle and make their way through the catacombs in search of a solution to their mystery.
Overall, the story was a lot of fun (especially for a comic book geek like me!) and the mystery was well-plotted. Even I was surprised by the identity of the culprit behind everything. Now to wait for the next book, when the boys return to Black Bear Mountain (the site of a previous mystery in this series)!
RATING: 10 lifeless bodies falling from the rafters out of 10 for proving beyond a shadow of a doubt that the Hardy Boys and Nancy Drew can still provide fantastic mysteries for kids today!
Monday, November 18, 2019
Draw the Line - an out of the ordinary super hero tale
Here is another one of those rare instances where I pick up a book that is NOT a series book - but the premise intrigues me enough that I step outside of my norm and give it a try. The reasons I picked up this book are pretty obvious - first, it deals with a young man who loves super heroes and who writes and draws his own online comic; second, it has actual comic pages within the book (which, it turns out, are pages from the protagonist's online comic); and third, it deals with that age-old struggle of a young gay man who is afraid to come out in a community and at a school who is very much antagonistic towards gay men. Bundle all three of these together, and there's a likelihood I will enjoy the read. And, I did.
Draw the Line is the story of Adrian Piper, a young high school student in a backwater Texas town. Adrian stays in the background, preferring not to be noticed. While he secretly publishes an online comic about a gay superhero, he keeps his own sexuality a secret (except from his two closest friends). Adrian expresses his dreams and fantasies through his comic book alter ego - but when a vicious hate crime happens right in front of him and his friends, Adrian does something he never thought possible - he stands up for the gay kid who was being attacked!
Author Laurent Linn tells a compelling story that is more than just a teenage coming out tale. This is a story about choosing to stand up for what is right. It's about conquering your fears and helping your fellow man, even when it could cost you everything. It's about asking yourself where do you draw the line when it comes to discrimination and bigotry? And considering this is Linn's first novel (which, by the way, he not only wrote, but he drew all of the illustrations found throughout the book!), I'd say he did an exceptional job!
As I reader, I easily found myself drawn into Adrian's world - identifying with his desire to just blend into the background, hoping to avoid all of the bullying and drama, while at the same time, wishing he could be that super hero that fights injustice, stands up for what is right, and is loved by everyone. I definitely found myself rooting for Adrian when he finally did take a stand, and getting angry when the police department and school refused to believe him, because the bully was the start quarterback (whose father happens to be on the police force). It's definitely a situation that occurs in the real world, where people are protected from the wrong-doing that they do simply because of their "star" status!).
What was not so real (but, which I realize was written simply for the storytelling aspect) was the fact that Adrian's crush happens to also have a crush on him - how many times in the real world does the little wallflower have a crush on one of the hottest guys in the class, and it turns out that the guy happens to also be gay and happens to also like the wallflower? That is Hallmark movie material, not real world identification. Yet, it does bring those "awwwwww" moments into the story and provides Adrian with a "reward" of sorts for all the trauma he faces once he decides to be honest with the world about who he is. There is, however, a very much real-world aspect to the story and the bully, which I won't specifically reveal here, as it will spoil the story, but let's just say that the author definitely got that part right!
Kind of a shame this is only a one-off book, as I would love to read more of the adventures of Adrian and his friends!
RATING: 10 rounds of Teen Drag Queen Bingo out of 10 for giving the world a not-so-typical coming out story with comic books and super heroes, in every sense of the word!
Draw the Line is the story of Adrian Piper, a young high school student in a backwater Texas town. Adrian stays in the background, preferring not to be noticed. While he secretly publishes an online comic about a gay superhero, he keeps his own sexuality a secret (except from his two closest friends). Adrian expresses his dreams and fantasies through his comic book alter ego - but when a vicious hate crime happens right in front of him and his friends, Adrian does something he never thought possible - he stands up for the gay kid who was being attacked!
Author Laurent Linn tells a compelling story that is more than just a teenage coming out tale. This is a story about choosing to stand up for what is right. It's about conquering your fears and helping your fellow man, even when it could cost you everything. It's about asking yourself where do you draw the line when it comes to discrimination and bigotry? And considering this is Linn's first novel (which, by the way, he not only wrote, but he drew all of the illustrations found throughout the book!), I'd say he did an exceptional job!
As I reader, I easily found myself drawn into Adrian's world - identifying with his desire to just blend into the background, hoping to avoid all of the bullying and drama, while at the same time, wishing he could be that super hero that fights injustice, stands up for what is right, and is loved by everyone. I definitely found myself rooting for Adrian when he finally did take a stand, and getting angry when the police department and school refused to believe him, because the bully was the start quarterback (whose father happens to be on the police force). It's definitely a situation that occurs in the real world, where people are protected from the wrong-doing that they do simply because of their "star" status!).
What was not so real (but, which I realize was written simply for the storytelling aspect) was the fact that Adrian's crush happens to also have a crush on him - how many times in the real world does the little wallflower have a crush on one of the hottest guys in the class, and it turns out that the guy happens to also be gay and happens to also like the wallflower? That is Hallmark movie material, not real world identification. Yet, it does bring those "awwwwww" moments into the story and provides Adrian with a "reward" of sorts for all the trauma he faces once he decides to be honest with the world about who he is. There is, however, a very much real-world aspect to the story and the bully, which I won't specifically reveal here, as it will spoil the story, but let's just say that the author definitely got that part right!
Kind of a shame this is only a one-off book, as I would love to read more of the adventures of Adrian and his friends!
RATING: 10 rounds of Teen Drag Queen Bingo out of 10 for giving the world a not-so-typical coming out story with comic books and super heroes, in every sense of the word!
Monday, November 11, 2019
Nancy Drew & The Hardy Boys: The Case of the Missing Adults (a Dynamite Graphic Novel)
So, I recently took a cruise with some of the cast of the old soap opera Santa Barbara, so that has put me behind in my blog posting - however, the cruise gave me an opportunity to do some more reading, including the new Nancy Drew and the Hardy Boys graphic novel from Dynamite Entertainment!
"The Case of the Missing Adults" is completely different from the prior two Dynamite forays into the Nancy Drew universe. "The Big Lie" was set in a dark, pulp world, while "The Case of the Cold Case" (a/k/a "The Palace of Wisdom") was simply a modern take on the teen detective. "The Case of the Missing Adults," however, takes Nancy, Frank, and Joe into a world for young readers to enjoy. The three teen detectives are still in high school, with Nancy having just moved from River Heights to Bayport (what is it with Dynamite wanting to make everything in Bayport???) and beginning her first day of school at Bayport High School. Needless to say, she runs into Frank and Joe and before you know it, the three are off to solve the mystery of what-in-the-world happened to all of the grown-ups?
The mystery is not complicated, and there are definitely a lot of childish jokes and silliness scattered throughout the story - but at its heart, writer Scott Bryan Wilson has captured the essence of Nancy Drew and the Hardy Boys - Nancy is single-minded and determined when it comes to solving a mystery and helping others, while Frank and Joe love to solve mysteries, but they also have a sibling rivalry going on that sometimes distracts them from the task at hand. Nevertheless, all three of these junior sleuths are quick-thinking, skilled with deductive reasoning, and aren't afraid to get their hands dirty to solve a crime!
The mystery itself involves an entire city of adults who go missing on Nancy's first day of school. The teachers are gone, the custodial and culinary staff are gone - heck, even the police are gone! Where did all the grown-ups go? While most of the kids in Bayport are loving the complete lack of supervision, Nancy, Frank and Joe know that something is afoot and start searching for answers. Could it have something to do with the upcoming science fair? And why is it that the adults in the nearby town of Vansant (Bayport's bitter rival) are still around, and life over there seems as beautiful and as perfect as ever? A come-to-life science skeleton, coded commercial, and a midnight van to Vansant provide Nancy and the Hardy Boys with the clues they need to find the culprit behind the mass kidnapping!
The art is somewhat rudimentary, as artist Bob Solanovicz creates a cartoony world where all of the teenagers, despite being high schoolers, all appear to be pre-teen in appearance. I realize this is the artistic style that seems to be the "in thing" right now with children's books (look at Diary of a Wimpy Kid, Dork Diaries, and similar books on the shelves right now, and you will see the very simplistic, somewhat childish art that graces the covers and interiors of those books), but this style of art does not truly appeal to me. While I did enjoy this story, the art was a huge detraction for me. That being said, with the art being what it is, and the story being so enjoyable (when read with a kid's perspective in mind), I could very easily see this graphic novel being made into a cartoon for television that would likely be very successful. It has all of the elements that seems to appeal to children today, and quite frankly, it would offer some much-needed role models for the children to look up to (something that is sorely missing in most cartoons and children's books today!).
I'm guessing there are plans (hopes?) for Dynamite to do more in this series of graphic novels, as the book ends with the statement, "Nancy Drew & the Hardy Boys will return to crack cases, do homework, and break hearts." The book also closes out with some character sketches by the artist, as well as some fun little "detective games," such as a crossword puzzle, a "spot the difference" game, a comic page to color, a connect-the-dots image, and a memory game. While not particularly difficult (for an adult), the games offer some fun activities for the children and pre-teens at whom the comic is aimed.
One final saving grace for the book is the fact that it comes in hardcover, with a glossy finish - making it perfect for shelving with the Nancy Drew books. I was expecting soft cover, so was surprised when it arrived and was hardcover format. A definite plus for the book!
RATING: 7 bowls of cold chili with corn chips out of 10 for bringing Nancy Drew and the Hardy Boys to yet another new audience with a cute little story that any age can enjoy!
"The Case of the Missing Adults" is completely different from the prior two Dynamite forays into the Nancy Drew universe. "The Big Lie" was set in a dark, pulp world, while "The Case of the Cold Case" (a/k/a "The Palace of Wisdom") was simply a modern take on the teen detective. "The Case of the Missing Adults," however, takes Nancy, Frank, and Joe into a world for young readers to enjoy. The three teen detectives are still in high school, with Nancy having just moved from River Heights to Bayport (what is it with Dynamite wanting to make everything in Bayport???) and beginning her first day of school at Bayport High School. Needless to say, she runs into Frank and Joe and before you know it, the three are off to solve the mystery of what-in-the-world happened to all of the grown-ups?
The mystery is not complicated, and there are definitely a lot of childish jokes and silliness scattered throughout the story - but at its heart, writer Scott Bryan Wilson has captured the essence of Nancy Drew and the Hardy Boys - Nancy is single-minded and determined when it comes to solving a mystery and helping others, while Frank and Joe love to solve mysteries, but they also have a sibling rivalry going on that sometimes distracts them from the task at hand. Nevertheless, all three of these junior sleuths are quick-thinking, skilled with deductive reasoning, and aren't afraid to get their hands dirty to solve a crime!
The mystery itself involves an entire city of adults who go missing on Nancy's first day of school. The teachers are gone, the custodial and culinary staff are gone - heck, even the police are gone! Where did all the grown-ups go? While most of the kids in Bayport are loving the complete lack of supervision, Nancy, Frank and Joe know that something is afoot and start searching for answers. Could it have something to do with the upcoming science fair? And why is it that the adults in the nearby town of Vansant (Bayport's bitter rival) are still around, and life over there seems as beautiful and as perfect as ever? A come-to-life science skeleton, coded commercial, and a midnight van to Vansant provide Nancy and the Hardy Boys with the clues they need to find the culprit behind the mass kidnapping!
The art is somewhat rudimentary, as artist Bob Solanovicz creates a cartoony world where all of the teenagers, despite being high schoolers, all appear to be pre-teen in appearance. I realize this is the artistic style that seems to be the "in thing" right now with children's books (look at Diary of a Wimpy Kid, Dork Diaries, and similar books on the shelves right now, and you will see the very simplistic, somewhat childish art that graces the covers and interiors of those books), but this style of art does not truly appeal to me. While I did enjoy this story, the art was a huge detraction for me. That being said, with the art being what it is, and the story being so enjoyable (when read with a kid's perspective in mind), I could very easily see this graphic novel being made into a cartoon for television that would likely be very successful. It has all of the elements that seems to appeal to children today, and quite frankly, it would offer some much-needed role models for the children to look up to (something that is sorely missing in most cartoons and children's books today!).
I'm guessing there are plans (hopes?) for Dynamite to do more in this series of graphic novels, as the book ends with the statement, "Nancy Drew & the Hardy Boys will return to crack cases, do homework, and break hearts." The book also closes out with some character sketches by the artist, as well as some fun little "detective games," such as a crossword puzzle, a "spot the difference" game, a comic page to color, a connect-the-dots image, and a memory game. While not particularly difficult (for an adult), the games offer some fun activities for the children and pre-teens at whom the comic is aimed.
One final saving grace for the book is the fact that it comes in hardcover, with a glossy finish - making it perfect for shelving with the Nancy Drew books. I was expecting soft cover, so was surprised when it arrived and was hardcover format. A definite plus for the book!
RATING: 7 bowls of cold chili with corn chips out of 10 for bringing Nancy Drew and the Hardy Boys to yet another new audience with a cute little story that any age can enjoy!
Labels:
comic,
graphic novel,
Hardy Boys,
mystery,
Nancy Drew,
series
Monday, November 4, 2019
Unsettled Things - A Pameroy Mystery in Kentucky
I will be the first to admit - I have been pretty lucky in the past when I've picked up new series to read. For the most part, I have enjoyed the books, and I have gone on to continue collecting and reading the various series. Some have been better than others, but only a very few have been so bad that I just decided to put a stop to it after finishing the first book. Unfortunately for the Pameroy Mystery series, this happens to be one of those very few cases.
Unsettled Things, which is the first Pameroy Mystery, caught my attention for two reasons - first, it featured a young protagonist who had supernatural intuition and could see and interact with ghosts; second, this first mystery is set in Kentucky, which is my home state where was born and raised. With these two things going for it, I pretty much figured I couldn't go wrong. Well, no bones about it - I was wrong!
The protagonist for the series is Lillia Pameroy - a twelve-year old girl with the knack for not only seeing ghosts, but also becoming immersed in visions of the past. Growing up, she was made to believe it was all in her imagination. An "imagining," she calls it. But for the first time, she is made to believe that these imaginings are more than just in her head. A visit with her grand aunt in the heart of Kentucky opens up a whole new world when Lillia sees a ghost, who appears to be leading her on a path that will not only put a restless spirit to rest, but also reunite long lost relatives. With the help of newfound friend Zoe, as well as some unexplained moments with the older Miss Margaret, Lillia faces not only the truth of her own abilities, but the truth about her family and how she fits in.
All in all, the plot to the book sounds like a great mystery. Unfortunately, author Brenda Felber does not succeed with the execution. First, and probably the worst part, is the fact that Lillia is not a likable character at all. She whines throughout the entire story, and none of her conflicts come across as real. Maybe it's me reading this from an adult perspective, but I didn't find anything at all complex or sincere about Lillia, and I felt absolutely no empathy for her predicament. Rather, she is written more as a spoiled little brat rather than a sympathetic young girl with the ability to see ghosts and into the past. I try and remember back to my younger days of reading, and even then, I don't see myself actually finding any redeeming qualities about Lillia that would have made me like her. In fact, I found Zoe to be a much more fascinating and rounded-out character in the story.
Second, the mystery itself felt very second-place to the story of Lillia and her family issues. It seems Lillia's mother previously lost a child, and Lillia was able to sense it, even as a small child. So, that creates some tension between Lillia and her mother; and when her father drops her off at her grand-aunt's house while he takes her younger brother on a trip, it leaves Lillia feeling more left out. And while these things might create a subtle undercurrent with most stories, they seem to always be thrown into the forefront of this book. There is actually very little of the mystery itself in the first half of the book, and there is no real active mystery-solving until the last one-fourth of the book, which made it difficult for me to keep pushing through, wondering when the mystery would actually begin.
Finally, the constant shifts between first-person point of view and third-person point of view were a bit jarring and clunky. The story would have been a much smoother read if Felber had simply maintained a consistent POV throughout the entire book. I personally think the third-person point of view would have read nicely, but I'm guessing the author felt it necessary to use first-person voice in order to give readers some insight into Lillia's mind. Unfortunately, it made the book more difficult to read.
Once the mystery starts, however, there are some good moments, such as when Lillia begins to see spirits from the past, and when she finds herself immersed in the home of one of the ghosts - for this moment reveals to her a secret connection to one of the townspeople who she and Zoe had agreed to help! Just wish there had been more great moments like this throughout the book, as it would have made it a much better read.
I'm planning to keep this book, simply because it is set in Kentucky, so I will keep it with my other series book set in my home state - however, I won't be picking up any more books in this series, as neither the character nor the writing are enough to hold my interest. Ah well, you win some, you lose some...
RATING: 3 servings of homemade mac and cheese out of 10 for the supernatural elements and the Kentucky setting.
Unsettled Things, which is the first Pameroy Mystery, caught my attention for two reasons - first, it featured a young protagonist who had supernatural intuition and could see and interact with ghosts; second, this first mystery is set in Kentucky, which is my home state where was born and raised. With these two things going for it, I pretty much figured I couldn't go wrong. Well, no bones about it - I was wrong!
The protagonist for the series is Lillia Pameroy - a twelve-year old girl with the knack for not only seeing ghosts, but also becoming immersed in visions of the past. Growing up, she was made to believe it was all in her imagination. An "imagining," she calls it. But for the first time, she is made to believe that these imaginings are more than just in her head. A visit with her grand aunt in the heart of Kentucky opens up a whole new world when Lillia sees a ghost, who appears to be leading her on a path that will not only put a restless spirit to rest, but also reunite long lost relatives. With the help of newfound friend Zoe, as well as some unexplained moments with the older Miss Margaret, Lillia faces not only the truth of her own abilities, but the truth about her family and how she fits in.
All in all, the plot to the book sounds like a great mystery. Unfortunately, author Brenda Felber does not succeed with the execution. First, and probably the worst part, is the fact that Lillia is not a likable character at all. She whines throughout the entire story, and none of her conflicts come across as real. Maybe it's me reading this from an adult perspective, but I didn't find anything at all complex or sincere about Lillia, and I felt absolutely no empathy for her predicament. Rather, she is written more as a spoiled little brat rather than a sympathetic young girl with the ability to see ghosts and into the past. I try and remember back to my younger days of reading, and even then, I don't see myself actually finding any redeeming qualities about Lillia that would have made me like her. In fact, I found Zoe to be a much more fascinating and rounded-out character in the story.Second, the mystery itself felt very second-place to the story of Lillia and her family issues. It seems Lillia's mother previously lost a child, and Lillia was able to sense it, even as a small child. So, that creates some tension between Lillia and her mother; and when her father drops her off at her grand-aunt's house while he takes her younger brother on a trip, it leaves Lillia feeling more left out. And while these things might create a subtle undercurrent with most stories, they seem to always be thrown into the forefront of this book. There is actually very little of the mystery itself in the first half of the book, and there is no real active mystery-solving until the last one-fourth of the book, which made it difficult for me to keep pushing through, wondering when the mystery would actually begin.
Finally, the constant shifts between first-person point of view and third-person point of view were a bit jarring and clunky. The story would have been a much smoother read if Felber had simply maintained a consistent POV throughout the entire book. I personally think the third-person point of view would have read nicely, but I'm guessing the author felt it necessary to use first-person voice in order to give readers some insight into Lillia's mind. Unfortunately, it made the book more difficult to read.
Once the mystery starts, however, there are some good moments, such as when Lillia begins to see spirits from the past, and when she finds herself immersed in the home of one of the ghosts - for this moment reveals to her a secret connection to one of the townspeople who she and Zoe had agreed to help! Just wish there had been more great moments like this throughout the book, as it would have made it a much better read.
I'm planning to keep this book, simply because it is set in Kentucky, so I will keep it with my other series book set in my home state - however, I won't be picking up any more books in this series, as neither the character nor the writing are enough to hold my interest. Ah well, you win some, you lose some...
RATING: 3 servings of homemade mac and cheese out of 10 for the supernatural elements and the Kentucky setting.
Wednesday, October 16, 2019
DC Super Hero Girls, Graphic Novel No. 8 - Spaced Out
And thus we come to the final (at least, for me) DC Super Hero Girls graphic novel. It's been a good run, more or less, and while not every one of the eight graphic novels were exceptional, I'd say that more were good than were not. It has been fun reading stories that were not continuity heavy, they weren't all doom and gloom, and the heroes, while less than perfect, were still - - well, heroes! With these young women (and the few young men), they may have doubted themselves and their abilities, but there was never any question of what was right and wrong. The stories were lighthearted, the adventures time- and universe-spanning, and the villains ultimately vanquished as they should be in any good superhero comic. But, alas, for reasons unknown to me, DC decided that these well-drawn characters and good-natured stories were just not good enough - so, they redesigned the Super Hero Girls (with art that I absolutely hate!) and changed the tone of the stories (from what was light-hearted and fun to what comes across as silly and childish) and introduced a whole new DC Super Hero Girls...but more on that later...
"Spaced Out" introduces Jessica Cruz Green Lantern to the DC Super Hero Girls universe. As in the DC Universe proper, this Jessica Cruz is fearful and not overly confident with her power ring. The story opens in Coach Wildcat's training class, where Jessica backs away from a fight with a monkey. Of course, she becomes even more afraid when Principal Waller informs her she must go to Oa, the planet of the Green Lanterns, for her official induction ceremony. Of course, she's not going alone - Big Barda, Star Sapphire, and Supergirl are going with her (along with a stowaway, but I won't spoil that surprise!). Thus, the girls' space adventure begins!
Meanwhile, back on Earth, Wonder Woman is supposed to be watching Krypto. But when Krypto takes off after Catwoman's cat, then gets loose in Metropolis and finds a stray dog with her litter, it takes Wonder Woman, Batgirl (along with Ace, the Bathound), Flash, and the whole DC Super Hero Girls crew to track down the missing dog. As such, readers are treated to two adventures within this one graphic novel!
It is fun to watch Jessica Cruz not only learn more about herself and her power ring through this adventure, but to see how she grows in courage with the help of her friends. The use of Zod, Non, and Faora as the villains was perfect, as it gave some simple conflict with Supergirl's desire to reconnect with people from her homeworld, while at the same time, utilizing villains with strength far above that of the other heroes - meaning that they have to work together to overcome the Kryptonian criminals. Writer Shea Fontana provides a very satisfying story (or should I say stories), and Agnes Garbowska provides art that blends seamlessly into the series (kind of a shame this is the last one, as her art was beautiful).
The book does at least acknowledge it's finality in the series, as writer Sholly Fisch and artist Marcelo DiChiara provide a mini-back-up story that has Zatanna showing the Super Hero Girls an alternate reality, where Harley Quinn, Poison Ivy, and Catwoman are criminals, the girls all have secret identities, and instead of Super Hero High, they are attending Metropolis High. It is an introduction to the new art style for the series, as well as a first look at the changes in the characters. I'm not a fan of this new direction, so rather than collecting it simply for the sake of completing a series, I've decided that this graphic novel will end my DC Super Hero Girls collection. And such a shame, as it has been a real jewel in the DC Comics world, and it's a shame that DC felt the need to change it.
So, goodbye DC Super Hero Girls - it was true pleasure reading your stories and sharing in your adventures, and know that this fan will miss the fun-loving stories that you've had along the way!
RATING: 9 bowls of Slurp-O-Slop ice cream out of 10 for giving the girls two fantastic stories as a fun-tabulous send off!
"Spaced Out" introduces Jessica Cruz Green Lantern to the DC Super Hero Girls universe. As in the DC Universe proper, this Jessica Cruz is fearful and not overly confident with her power ring. The story opens in Coach Wildcat's training class, where Jessica backs away from a fight with a monkey. Of course, she becomes even more afraid when Principal Waller informs her she must go to Oa, the planet of the Green Lanterns, for her official induction ceremony. Of course, she's not going alone - Big Barda, Star Sapphire, and Supergirl are going with her (along with a stowaway, but I won't spoil that surprise!). Thus, the girls' space adventure begins!
Meanwhile, back on Earth, Wonder Woman is supposed to be watching Krypto. But when Krypto takes off after Catwoman's cat, then gets loose in Metropolis and finds a stray dog with her litter, it takes Wonder Woman, Batgirl (along with Ace, the Bathound), Flash, and the whole DC Super Hero Girls crew to track down the missing dog. As such, readers are treated to two adventures within this one graphic novel!
It is fun to watch Jessica Cruz not only learn more about herself and her power ring through this adventure, but to see how she grows in courage with the help of her friends. The use of Zod, Non, and Faora as the villains was perfect, as it gave some simple conflict with Supergirl's desire to reconnect with people from her homeworld, while at the same time, utilizing villains with strength far above that of the other heroes - meaning that they have to work together to overcome the Kryptonian criminals. Writer Shea Fontana provides a very satisfying story (or should I say stories), and Agnes Garbowska provides art that blends seamlessly into the series (kind of a shame this is the last one, as her art was beautiful).
The book does at least acknowledge it's finality in the series, as writer Sholly Fisch and artist Marcelo DiChiara provide a mini-back-up story that has Zatanna showing the Super Hero Girls an alternate reality, where Harley Quinn, Poison Ivy, and Catwoman are criminals, the girls all have secret identities, and instead of Super Hero High, they are attending Metropolis High. It is an introduction to the new art style for the series, as well as a first look at the changes in the characters. I'm not a fan of this new direction, so rather than collecting it simply for the sake of completing a series, I've decided that this graphic novel will end my DC Super Hero Girls collection. And such a shame, as it has been a real jewel in the DC Comics world, and it's a shame that DC felt the need to change it.
So, goodbye DC Super Hero Girls - it was true pleasure reading your stories and sharing in your adventures, and know that this fan will miss the fun-loving stories that you've had along the way!
RATING: 9 bowls of Slurp-O-Slop ice cream out of 10 for giving the girls two fantastic stories as a fun-tabulous send off!
Sunday, October 13, 2019
A Ted Wilford Mystery, no. 6 - The Counterfeit Mystery
This sixth Ted Wilford mystery was not overly exciting - however, it was definitely a product of its time! Of course, the entire series is a product of its time (no cell phones, no computers, etc.), so when reading the books, I have to remind myself of that fact. However, just because it is a story out of time does not mean that it can't be exciting, or that it shouldn't be enjoyable from the first page. But I have discovered that these Ted Wilford mysteries are sort of hit and miss - some are really good, while some are not quite that good (and the mystery not overly engaging). Sadly, this one falls into the latter category.
The Counterfeit Mystery is set during the summer following his graduation from high school and just before he is ready to leave for college. He doesn't have much work at the newspaper, and just when he thinks he will have a lot of free time the last few weeks of his summer vacation, he gets a call from Mr. Dobson, the editor at the town newspaper. Along with newcomer Nancy Lindell (who happens to be he niece of the newspaper's secretary), Ted is brought into the editor's office to meet Mr. Woodring - a salesman set to introduce a whole new concept to Forestdale - trading stamps! I had to smile when I read this, as I realized that most people I know today would have no idea what trading stamps are (and no, it doesn't mean collecting postal stamps and trading them as you would baseball cards or comics!).
For those who don't know, trading stamps were stamps that a person could collect every time they went shopping. For every dollar you spent, you earned a certain amount of stamps. You collected the stamps in books, and when you had a certain number of books, you could redeem them for various things - from dishes, to utensils, to pots and pans, to toys, to any number of items. The more an item was worth, the more books of stamps were required to be redeemed to get it. Additionally, you could purchase an item using both stamps and money - for instance, if you wanted a bicycle, and it cost you 250 books of stamps, but you didn't want to wait that long - sometimes, there was a special offer, and you could get the bicycle by redeeming 100 books of stamps plus $100 (that's just an example, so don't go trying to go search and see if that is accurate). I can remember back in the day when I was a kid, my mom collected Green Stamps, but I don't remember if she ever had enough to redeem them for anything (she probably did, and I just never paid attention, as I was too worried about toys and Nancy Drew books LOL!).
In any event, Ted doesn't seem thrilled with the whole concept, but Mr. Woodring convinces the paper's editor, who agrees to endorse it. Plus, Mr. Dobson has volunteered Ted's services to act as his assistant while he is in town trying to drum up business for the stamp sales. Ted chooses to use the opportunity to keep an eye on Mr. Woodring and make sure the entire thing is on the up-and-up. It ultimately pays off, since the stamps that start showing up are a purple shade, while the original stamps that Mr. Woodring showed Ted and the others in Mr. Dobson's office were blue! Is Mr. Woodring counterfeiting the stamps, or is something else going on?
In the meantime, Ted gets to know more about Nancy and discovers that she has come to town for an ulterior motive. It seems her grandmother makes mention in some of her letters of a town named Freeport in the state, but it seems no one has ever heard of it! Neither Ted nor Nancy can find any mention of it in the newspapers or other books in the local library, and even some of the older townsfolks have never heard of it. How could a whole town disappear?
The counterfeit stamps part of the mystery is rather tame, and the clues to that pretty much fall into Ted's lap without him actually having to look for them (except for when Mr. Woodring disappears, then Ted has to take action to actually hunt the man down). His and Nancy's efforts to locate the ever elusive Freeport seems to find them doing active clue-hunting, but to no avail. And, like pretty much every children's mystery story written, the two mysteries are eventually determined to have a connection, and solving one leads to the solution of the other.
The one element of this story I did find somewhat interesting was Ted and Nelson's trip to Hobotown, an area of the city where the hobos tended to congregate and set up temporary "homes." They are looking for Mr. Woodring, and the clues lead them to this community of hobos, and it was rather intriguing to see how author Norvin Pallas portrayed the people. Pallas wrote them as a tight-knit group of men who looked out for one another, had a code of honor, and did not tolerate outsiders; yet, the do decide to help Ted in his mystery, providing a very important clue to help him solve the case.
I only have two more books from the series - books 7 and 11. While 8 of the books in the series have been reprinted in paperback editions, for whatever reason, the remaining 7 books are only available on e-readers, which I refuse to get. So, once I read those last two books, then my reading of Ted Wilford mysteries will have reached its end...
RATING: 7 purple cows out of 10 for bringing back memories of my youth and my Mom with an outdated program that I hadn't thought of in years!
The Counterfeit Mystery is set during the summer following his graduation from high school and just before he is ready to leave for college. He doesn't have much work at the newspaper, and just when he thinks he will have a lot of free time the last few weeks of his summer vacation, he gets a call from Mr. Dobson, the editor at the town newspaper. Along with newcomer Nancy Lindell (who happens to be he niece of the newspaper's secretary), Ted is brought into the editor's office to meet Mr. Woodring - a salesman set to introduce a whole new concept to Forestdale - trading stamps! I had to smile when I read this, as I realized that most people I know today would have no idea what trading stamps are (and no, it doesn't mean collecting postal stamps and trading them as you would baseball cards or comics!).
For those who don't know, trading stamps were stamps that a person could collect every time they went shopping. For every dollar you spent, you earned a certain amount of stamps. You collected the stamps in books, and when you had a certain number of books, you could redeem them for various things - from dishes, to utensils, to pots and pans, to toys, to any number of items. The more an item was worth, the more books of stamps were required to be redeemed to get it. Additionally, you could purchase an item using both stamps and money - for instance, if you wanted a bicycle, and it cost you 250 books of stamps, but you didn't want to wait that long - sometimes, there was a special offer, and you could get the bicycle by redeeming 100 books of stamps plus $100 (that's just an example, so don't go trying to go search and see if that is accurate). I can remember back in the day when I was a kid, my mom collected Green Stamps, but I don't remember if she ever had enough to redeem them for anything (she probably did, and I just never paid attention, as I was too worried about toys and Nancy Drew books LOL!).
In any event, Ted doesn't seem thrilled with the whole concept, but Mr. Woodring convinces the paper's editor, who agrees to endorse it. Plus, Mr. Dobson has volunteered Ted's services to act as his assistant while he is in town trying to drum up business for the stamp sales. Ted chooses to use the opportunity to keep an eye on Mr. Woodring and make sure the entire thing is on the up-and-up. It ultimately pays off, since the stamps that start showing up are a purple shade, while the original stamps that Mr. Woodring showed Ted and the others in Mr. Dobson's office were blue! Is Mr. Woodring counterfeiting the stamps, or is something else going on?
In the meantime, Ted gets to know more about Nancy and discovers that she has come to town for an ulterior motive. It seems her grandmother makes mention in some of her letters of a town named Freeport in the state, but it seems no one has ever heard of it! Neither Ted nor Nancy can find any mention of it in the newspapers or other books in the local library, and even some of the older townsfolks have never heard of it. How could a whole town disappear?
The counterfeit stamps part of the mystery is rather tame, and the clues to that pretty much fall into Ted's lap without him actually having to look for them (except for when Mr. Woodring disappears, then Ted has to take action to actually hunt the man down). His and Nancy's efforts to locate the ever elusive Freeport seems to find them doing active clue-hunting, but to no avail. And, like pretty much every children's mystery story written, the two mysteries are eventually determined to have a connection, and solving one leads to the solution of the other.
The one element of this story I did find somewhat interesting was Ted and Nelson's trip to Hobotown, an area of the city where the hobos tended to congregate and set up temporary "homes." They are looking for Mr. Woodring, and the clues lead them to this community of hobos, and it was rather intriguing to see how author Norvin Pallas portrayed the people. Pallas wrote them as a tight-knit group of men who looked out for one another, had a code of honor, and did not tolerate outsiders; yet, the do decide to help Ted in his mystery, providing a very important clue to help him solve the case.
I only have two more books from the series - books 7 and 11. While 8 of the books in the series have been reprinted in paperback editions, for whatever reason, the remaining 7 books are only available on e-readers, which I refuse to get. So, once I read those last two books, then my reading of Ted Wilford mysteries will have reached its end...
RATING: 7 purple cows out of 10 for bringing back memories of my youth and my Mom with an outdated program that I hadn't thought of in years!
Labels:
mystery,
Norvin Pallas,
series,
stamps,
Ted Wilford,
young adult
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)






