Thursday, November 10, 2022

Cold-Blooded Myrtle - a Myrtle Hardcastle Mystery #3

Christmas is almost arrived at Swinburne in this third Myrtle Hardcastle mystery.  After solving the murder of her neighbor and the murder at a seaside resort, one would think that twelve-year old Myrtle Hardcastle deserves a break - but as we all know, mystery never takes a vacation, especially for young sleuths like Myrtle!  Author Elizabeth C. Bunce returns with probably her best murder mystery yet!  And while it took me a bit to get into this book (I guess it's been too long since I read the second mystery, so other than her governess, Miss Judson, I had a difficult time re-acquainting myself with the rest of Myrtle's supporting cast - I suppose that's a price one pays for reading as many different on-going series as I do!), once I got a few chapters in, I was thoroughly hooked!

Cold-Blooded Myrtle is set right at Christmas time, as the villagers in Swinburne are gearing up for a snowy, freezing holiday.  There's quite a bit going on - the unveiling of Leighton Mercantile's window display for the season ... the opening of the new display at the local museum, showcasing items (coincidentally enough) donated by Professor Leighton ... and the ever-difficult hunt for the perfect Christmas gift for one's family and friends.  Myrtle is worried because Christmas is nearly there, and she has yet to find that hard-to-find gift for her governess.  But she needn't have worried - soon enough, another mystery falls right in their laps, and they are too busy trying to catch a killer to worry about the perfect gift!

Bunce crafts a wonderfully hard-to-figure-out mystery that stumps not only Myrtle and Miss Judson, but the reader as well.  Usually I am pretty good at figuring these things out fairly early on, but Bunce had be guessing on this one until very nearly the end!  It all starts when Leighton Mercantile pulls back its curtains on the amazing window display that Professor Leighton crafts each year - a perfect replica of the village, down to the citizens in the street.  Only this year, the display has an added surprise - a tiny replica of a well, painted black, with a twig of olives placed next to it.  But that's not the only surprise - because once inside the store, Myrtle and Miss Judson, alongside Mrs. Leighton, discover the dead body of Professor Leighton, resting in a chair, a cup of tea by his side and a note in his hand.  For all intent and purposes, it seems Professor Leighton had a stroke, which is what the arriving doctor immediately assumes.  But Myrtle has questions, especially after she finds a photograph of Professor Leighton lying near the scene - an old photo that shows Professor Leighton with some of his students, one of whom happens to be Myrtle's very own mother!

Myrtle's father, of course, is none too happy to find his daughter at the scene of yet another dead body, but since this appears natural, he is not too worried.  Until the attending physician reveals Professor Leighton to have been poisoned - and that he had traces of chloroform around his mouth, which meant someone had murdered the kindly old man.  But why?  Who could possibly have a grudge against a former college professor and owner of the local mercantile?  Well, when Myrtle describes the display in Leighton's window to her father, she discovers the mystery hits a lot closer to home than she could have ever realized - because when she describes the display, her father's first question is, "What color was the well?"  When she tells him it was painted black, he surprises her with an unexpected response.  "Olive, black well ... Olive Blackwell?  What would he put that on display?" (p. 23).  And so begins Myrtle's search for a solution to not only the current mystery, but also the mystery of whatever really happened to one of her mother's college friends - one Olive Blackwell.  The story goes that she fell from the top of the campanile (old bell tower), but her body was never discovered, and no one quite knows what happened.  But as Myrtle soon discovers, someone might know - several someones, in fact, all of whom live in Swinburne and all of whom are familiar to Myrtle.  Myrtle's mother, who died of cancer.  Professor Leighton, who is now dead.  The newly elected Mayor of Swinburne, the father of Myrtle's nemesis, LaRue Spence-Hastings.  Dr. Munjal, the father of Myrtle's friend, Caroline.  and Nora Carmichael, an archaeologist, and her brother David.  But it seems David is also dead, having died while mountain climbing some time ago.  So that only leaves three.  Three people who seem awfully desperate to keep a secret from years ago.  Is one of them the killer?

Oh, and let's not forget Imogen Shelley, the nosy reporter for the loan newspaper who seems to be right in the middle of things, sensationalizing everything she writes about the case.  It turns out, however, that she has a connection with one Mr. Blakeney, a solicitor-in-training who Myrtle previously met in her prior adventures.  And it also turns out that Ms. Shelley has had an unhealthy obsession with the Olive Blackwell case for some time - but is it one that would drive her to murder?

Myrtle and Miss Judson (and, oh yes, Peony, too) have a very difficult time sifting through the clues and the suspects to figure out whodunnit - and when a second body turns up, they realize the clock is ticking, because the window display was changed just before the second murder.  So, when the display is changed again, it's only a matter of time before the third murder occurs!  Bunce writes plenty of suspense, danger, and surprises in this one, and I willingly admit I could not for the life of me figure this one out until almost the end - and when the revelation comes, it suddenly all makes perfect sense.

I've said it before, and I'll say it again - I would SO recommend this series to anyone who enjoys a great murder mystery.  Bunce writes a wonderful mystery, full of fantastic characters, and provides a more than satisfying read in each and every book.  Definitely looking forward to the next one!

RATING:  10 engraved miner's helmets out of 10 for murder, mayhem, and mystery at Christmas time that is well worth reading!

Sunday, November 6, 2022

Penny Parker Mystery Stories No. 4 - Behind the Green Door

As we continue reading through the Penny Parker books, I can see why people enjoy this series so much.  While the third book was not necessarily the best, it still offered up a pretty good mystery, and the character of Penny Parker is one you can't help but love.  She's plucky, she's determined, she's sarcastic, she's nosy, she's unwilling to back down, and she's always ready to jump in and help someone in need.  She is everything you want out of a girl sleuth and then some.  And author Mildred Wirt had the freedom with Penny that she never had with Nancy Drew when she was writing for the Syndicate, as, after the first three books, Harriet Stratemeyer Adams began to tighten the reigns on the character.  So, it has been fun reading the Penny Parker books, comparing them not only with the Nancy Drew books, but with other books of the time, and looking into some of the historical references scattered throughout the series.  And while the title to this fourth book may conjure up a rather elicit adult film by the same name (we'll take a look at that coincidence later), the story is definitely one of Wirt's better ones so far.

Behind the Green Door opens with Penny preparing to take a trip up to Pine Top, where she will enjoy a holiday vacation of skiing.  It is funny that in Mystery of the Brass-Bound Trunk, published the same year as this book, Nancy is preparing to take a trip as well (only she's going on a cruise, not a ski trip)!  Penny is practicing her skills inside the house (and that must be a pretty large house for Penny to slide across the floor on an "open christiana" or a "telemark").  There is some definite humor in this opening chapter when Penny informs the Parkers' housekeeper that she has bought a new pair of skis, a couple of poles, three different kinds of wax, and a pair of red mittens, to which the housekeeper dryly replies, "Why didn't you order the store sent out and be done with it?" (p. 3).  It's this kind of quick wit that gives Penny Parker a sense of realism, as remarks like this are exactly the kind of things I would say!

Needless to say, the vacation doesn't start off as planned, as Mr. Parker is unable to join his daughter, due to the fact his newspaper is being sued for libel - to the tune of $50,000 (which, in today's dollars, would be nearly $1 million in today's dollars!).  It seems a local football player told the paper that Harvey Maxwell (who own a large chain of hotels) paid him to throw a game - but after the story was published, he recanted his story, and now Maxwell is suing for libel (pp. 6-7).  Penny is disappointed, but she still makes the trip by plane to Pine Top, located near the Canadian border - and what an interesting flight it is!  First, Penny is confronted with Francine Sellberg of the Riverview Record, a newspaper rival of her father, who Penny is confident is going to Pine Top to cover a story.  Second, Penny has the good fortune of sitting just behind two men on the plane who apparently have some very untoward plans regarding Mrs. Downey's hotel - the very same hotel where Penny will be staying!  And third, while we are never given a definitely location for Penny's home town of Riverview, it's location becomes even more mystifying when you consider this plane flight from Riverview to Pine Top takes over 24 hours to complete (including a short layover and a flight through the night, during which Penny curls up in "her clean, comfortable bed" [p. 31] on the plane, and even changes into fresh clothes in the morning when she wakes up [p. 32]).  

The mystery begins soon after Penny arrives at Downey Lodge and discovers that business has been decreasing since the opening of the Fergus Hotel not far from there - a hotel financed by none other than Harvey Maxwell!  It seems Fergus has been luring guests away from Downey Lodge and has made repeated attempts to buy Mrs. Downey's property.  Up until now, Mrs. Downey has been reluctant to sell, but with business dwindling, she may have no choice.  Penny pays a visit to Fergus Hotel, to check out the competition in hopes of helping Mrs. Downey, and it is there she hears about the "Green Room," which is Room 22 and for which one must have a special card to be admitted.  Her curiosity piqued, Penny sets about finding out what's in that room.  But if you think that's the only mystery Penny has to face in this book, think again!  She also happens upon a young girl being held captive by her grandfather in her own home there on the mountainside, and Penny decides to help the young girl.  There is also the unexplained mystery of why Fergus Hotel continues to get daily newspapers, when Downey Lodge is lucky to receive one a week.  And how does the actress, Maxine Miller, fit into all of this?

Poor Penny definitely faces her fair share of trouble in this book.  She nearly wipes out into some barbed wire that surrounds the Jasko property (where the young girl is held prisoner), and she gets badly injured when she has to jump out of a runaway bobsled to act as its brake and keep it from sliding off the track (yeah, it sounds outrageous, but it really happens in the story!).  With her right arm swollen, her skin severely scraped and bruised from her hip to her ankle, and her neck injured to the point where she can't turn it (p. 130), one would think Penny would be out of the game for a while.  But her determination has her up and about just two days later - although the timeline here is a bit loose, since Ms. Miller tells Penny she heard about her bobsled incident "yesterday" (p. 140), despite two days having passed (sleeping until dinner on p. 131, then awakening the next morning on p. 139).  Penny keeps up her detective work, and ultimately has to save Mr. Jasko, who is kidnapped (p. 180) and finds the real reason Fergus and Maxwell want to buy up all the property on Pine Top Mountain (p. 195), putting a stop to their nefarious plans, saving the day for Sara Jasko and her grandfather, and getting the scoop for her father's newspaper - all in a day's work for an ace amateur sleuth like Penny Parker!

And just in case you wondering about more Nancy Drew similarities - well, Penny does happen across a hidden staircase that leads to the basement and a narrow tunnel (p. 183); and one has to wonder if the plot for this book, involving skiing and smuggled furs, was an inspiration of sorts for the Mystery at the Ski Jump, published in 1952, some twelve years later.

Now, in case you are wondering about that "adult film" reference - yes, there really was an adult film released in 1972 by the same name, Behind the Green Door, starring Marilyn Chambers.  While the movie featured a posh hotel that had a secret room that only people "in the know" could enter, and yes, it featured a green door, behind which was a secret to be discovered - those are the only similarities to the book.  What is rather interesting, though, is the film is said to be based on a short story titled "The Abduction of Gloria," which is believed to have been written around 1940 - the very same year this book was published!  Now, if that isn't an odd coincidence!  However, doing some research, it seems the "green door" has a historical reference dating back to the prohibition era, when a secret entrance toa  private club (speakeasy) was often painted green, so that clients "in the know" would know where to go to find alcohol.  There is also a short story by O. Henry from the 1906 book, The Four Million, titled "The Green Door," in which a man is handed a card with the words The Green Room on them, leaving the man to wonder what mystery lies behind the green door.  So, while there is a very slight coincidence between the film and this book, it is highly unlikely there is any real connection - other than the use of the name.

Finally, my good friend, Geoffrey Lapin, recalls that somewhere in his research, he discovered that Mildred Wirt's original manuscript for Behind the Green Door was to be published as a sequel to one of her other books, Connie Carl at Rainbow Ranch; however, that did not happen, so Wirt revised the manuscript for her fourth Penny Parker book.  Unfortunately, there is no documented evidence to support this, so for now, it is yet another mystery in children's series books that will likely never be solved...

Before signing off, there is one scene from the book that I have to mention.  Penny is always one to speak her mind, but when she finally confronts Mr. Jasko, not only about his refusal to renew Mrs. Downey's lease to use the slopes for which he owns the land, but also about holding his granddaughter captive in her own home, she really lets him have it.  I found myself cheering for calling him out on his selfish actions (something Nancy Drew would never be allowed to do!).  "You don't care how much trouble you cause other folks.  Because of your own son's death you have taken an unnatural attitude toward skiing.  You hate everything remotely connected with the sport. But it isn't fair.  Your granddaughter has a right to a certain amount of freedom" (p. 158).  Good for Penny!  Would it be that all of us would stand up against injustice and unfairness like this!

RATING:  10 girls stimulating as a mountain avalanche out of 10 for a mystery jam-packed with characters, adventure, secrets, hidden passages, locked rooms, and criminal mischief!

Wednesday, November 2, 2022

Sisterhood of Sleuths - an Homage to the Classic Nancy Drew Mystery Stories

This book was a spur-of-the moment purchase that turned out to be a truly unexpected joy to read.  I saw this book on "new releases" shelf at my local Barnes & Noble and nearly passed it up.  But the title snagged my attention, so I looked inside to see what it was about.  While the tagline did not really do it for me, the first line of the description sold me right away:  "So when a box full of vintage Nancy Drew books gets left at her mom's thrift store, Maizy is surprised to find an old photo of her grandmother and two other women tucked beneath the collection."  I didn't have to read any further to know I was buying the book.  Any mystery that deals with Nancy Drew books as a part of the mystery is sure to be a fun read!  And author Jennifer Chambliss Bertman did not disappoint in the least.

Sisterhood of Sleuths is not just a mystery - it is also a coming-of-age story about a young girl who hasn't yet let go of the loves of her childhood, while her best friend seems to be growing up.  Maisy and her best friend Izzy are supposed to be filming a genre movie for their sixth grade class; but Maisy is quickly discovering that Izzy - or "Isabelle" as she now wants to be called - no longer has an interest in the film Maisy has written.  Isabelle has developed a sudden interest in boys, and make-up, and other things that still seem foreign to Maisy.  But that box of Nancy Drew books dropped off at her mom's thrift store proves to be a catalyst that changes Maisy's life in so many ways.

First, and foremost, is that old photograph of Maisy's grandmother with two other women.  Why does Maisy's grandmother claim that it is not her, when Maisy can clearly see that it is?  And why does her grandmother remain adamant that she did not donate the books, when Maisy's mother is certain it was her? And if she did not leave them, then who did?  Maisy wants to investigate, but Isabelle has other things in mind - like Link and Ben, two boys from their class.  And when Isabelle brings the boys, along with Link's twin sister, Cam, into the fold for their school project, Maisy finds the movie she had written is no longer hers at all!  By happenstance (and how often does that happen in a Nancy Drew book!), their teacher is not overly thrilled with Maisy's former friend, Nell, working alone on a project, so Maisy finds herself moved into a new team with Nell and Cam - and their project evolves from a fashion show featuring designs by Nell to a documentary about Nancy Drew - starting with who left those books at the thrift store!

Bertman crafts a wonderfully fun mystery that thoroughly integrates the love of Nancy Drew, the mystery of Nancy Drew, and the mysteries behind the writers of Nancy Drew.  She perfectly captures the feeling a young person of today might have when first introduced to Nancy Drew books - somewhat uncertain, but curious enough to give them a try.  And when Maisy, Cam, and Nell (a la Nancy [the sleuth], George [the tomboy], Bess [the fashion-conscious one]) learn that Carolyn Keene never really existed, but was just a pseudonym, it opens up a whole new mystery for them to solve, and further expands the perimeters of their documentary.  It is fun to follow their growing excitement as they not only read the books but research the truth behind the Stratemeyer Syndicate and the various writers who wrote Nancy Drew over the years - in particular, Mildred Wirt Benson, the very first author.  And Bertman manages to insert some great surprises into the story that will make any Nancy Drew fan giggle with excitement when they read it!  And in the tradition of those original Nancy Drew books, this book even offers the reader some great illustrations to compliment the story, drawn by Vesper Stamper.
 
The book offers up plenty of historical information about Nancy Drew, including her creation, her authors, her publishers, her scandals, and so much more.  It is easy to see that Bertman did her research for this, and I love how she manages to seamlessly slide all of that information into the story so naturally, where it does not feel like just textbook information, but rather, like clues that the girls are finding as they look for the solution to the bigger mystery.

I thoroughly enjoyed this book, so much, in fact, that I finished it in less than a day - I just couldn't put it down!  The whole generational love of Nancy Drew, and the shared experiences of finding the books and unlocking the mysteries behind the series is such a great reflection on the number of real-life fans who found their love of Nancy Drew from their mothers, sisters, aunts, grandmothers, and other relatives, and have gone on to share it with their children.  By the time I finished the book, I realized just how appropriate the title to the book is - because whether it is within the story or in the real world, there truly is a Sisterhood of Sleuths out there who have a shared love of Nancy Drew, a fictional character that has endured nearly 100 years, and has inspired more people than we could possibly count.  Fleur Bradley says it write in her quote on the back of the book - "The perfect book for mystery fans of all ages - a classic that explores the Nancy Drew icon in a contemporary light."   I don't think there is any other perfect way to describe this book than that.

HIGHLY RECOMMENDED!!!!

RATING: 10 blue cloches out of 10 for an absolutely wonderful homage to Nancy Drew and her plethora of fans, with a door that hopefully opens to countless new fans to seek out the timeless teenage detective!

Saturday, October 29, 2022

Short(est) Lived Comic Series #24 - Gil Thorp (Dell Comics)

Growing up, I remember seeing the Gil Thorp comic strip in the funny pages of The Courier Journal and Louisville Times (don't really remember which it was in - the Journal was our morning paper, the Times was our afternoon paper).  I never paid it much attention, since it was about sports, and as anyone who knows me knows, sports is the absolute LAST thing in the world I care about or would ever want to read about!  When we moved to Florida, I never gave that strip another thought - until over this past summer, while at a local comic convention, I came across a rather inexpensive copy of a Dell Comic that was in unbelievably great condition of ... yup, you guessed it ... Gil Thorp!

Gil Thorp is a newspaper strip that was created and originally written and drawn by Jack Berrill.  Online sources reveal that Berrill worked on the strip from the date of its creation back in 1958 until he died in 1996 (nearly 40 years - I'd say that's a pretty good chunk of time for a writer/artist to work on a daily strip!).  After Berrill died, Jerry Jenkins took over the writing, which surprised me, as I recognize his name from the Left Behind series of books.  Apparently, Jenkins only stayed with the strip until 2004, when Detroit News columnist Neal Rubin took over the writing chores.  Rubin stuck around for 18 years on the strip, and this year, graphic novel writer Henry Barajas became the new writer on the strip.  From what I can find online, it appears there were a number of artists who drew the strip once Berrill was no longer able - William Sattler, Frank Bolle, Ray Burns, Frank McLaughlin, and the current artist, Rod Whigham.  Having never read the strip, I can't say whether the writing and art remained consistent through the changes over the years, but considering the fact the strip is still being published, I guess it must have something going for it.

So, when I came across this comic at the convention, I did a quick online search and discovered that Dell only published one issue of the Gil Thorp comic, even though the indicia on the inside first page indicates it is "No. 1" and states the comic is "Published quarterly..."  Don't know if any other issues were planned, or if it was always intended to be just a one-off. Since it was only a one-issue comic, and it was not at all expensive, I thought to myself, "Why not?"  The cover is a beautifully painted scene of Gil Thorp watching two high school baseball players as one sldes into the plate, and the other tries to catch the ball.  The tagline on the cover reads "With the new baseball season, a serious problem arises for Coach Thorp!"  Obviously, Thorp is going to face some king of drama/dilemma in coaching the baseball team, which creates the conflict for the story.

Sadly, back in those days, the comic companies (particularly smaller companies like Dell, Gold Key, etc.) did not give credit to any of the creators within the comic.  As such, I have no way of knowing for sure who wrote the story and who provided the pencils, inks, colors, lettering, etc.  I will say, though, the art is very clean-cut, and the artist manages to give distinct appearances to each of the characters so they are easily discernible from one another.  The  backgrounds are not very detailed, except on a few occasions when we see some books on a bookshelf (p. 8) or stone details on a sidewalk and the side of a house (p. 12).  Otherwise, the backgrounds are kept simple, which actually works, as it keeps the focus of the story on the characters, while at the same time giving the feel of a comic strip (which, more often than not, are not very detailed).  One website I found (Gil Thorp) lists the artist as Eddie Robbins, with the caveat that Robbins was trying to imitate the style of Thorp creator, Jack Berrill.  Whether this is true or not, I have no idea.

The story itself has Thorp being asked to take over as coach for Milford High's baseball team after the previous coach suddenly resigns.  Thorp finds himself faced with resentment from the high school boys, all of whom loved their prior coach, and he especially finds trouble when it comes to one particular boy, Bob Burwell, who is determined to play short stop and his father will do anything to ensure that happens - even if that means trying to get Thorp fired!  The story focuses on Thorp trying to get the boys to work together as a team, rather than trying to impress scouts with their individual talents, and Burwell causes many a problem along the way.  Of course, a small level of romance is thrown into the mix, as Burwell's sister finds herself attracted to Coach Thorp, and she is placed in the middle between her brother and father wanting Thorp out of the picture and Thorp trying to teach Bob Burwell the importance of teamwork and taking responsibility for one's own actions.

I can't deny that the story was not exactly thrilling - unlike superhero or crime comics, there are no big fights, no dangerous shoot-outs, and no unexpected surprises.  About the closest thing you get is when two thugs try to convince Burwell to throw a game so that they can win some big money - but he does not hesitate to tell his father and Thorp, who set up a trap to catch the men.  The comic is basically alla about Thorp trying to teach the boys a lesson that will help them later in life, and it ends with a moral being instilled, and both Burwell men coming to realize the error of their ways.  The story is what you would expect from a tale published in 1963 - very clean cut, right always wins, and nothing untoward or scandalous that might offend anyone (although, viewing it from today's standards, I'm sure people would take offense to the fact that the comic has only white characters - there are no minority characters whatsoever).
 
I guess I should be grateful that there was only one issue, as I honestly don't think I'd be interested in reading another sports story about Coach Gil Thorp.  Sports fans may enjoy the comic, but, no, this one was not for me.
 
RATING:  6 wicked bouncers toward third out of 10 for at least giving the strip a try as a full-length comic.

Tuesday, October 25, 2022

Gothic for Girls: MISTY and British Comics

I ordered this book through Previews some time ago, but I have not had the time to sit down and read it.  I'm much more of a fiction than non-fiction fan when it comes to reading, so I let this book sit for a while before finally deciding it was time to dig in.  Ever since I first started reading (comics AND books), I have loved certain things the most:  mystery ... horror ... supernatural ... female protagonists ... Gothic.  Until I saw the ad for this book in Previews, I had never heard of Misty before.  I was aware that Britain had been famous for publishing their weekly comics, some of which were aimed at girls (I have quite a number of the Schoolgirls Weekly newspapers, which feature a young detective named Valerie Drew, as well as a few copies of The School Friend and Girls' Crystal), but I was unaware that they had published some newspapers for girls that were ... well, for lack of a better word, darker.  Needless to say, I ordered the book to find out more about this Misty series, and let me tell you - after reading this book, I definitely want to track down all 101issues!
 
Now, let me preface this by saying that I have loved Gothic for as long as I can remember.  I grew up watching reruns of Dark Shadows (the only true Gothic soap opera),  reading comics such as The Dark Mansion of Forbidden Love by DC Comics, and reading mysteries about hidden staircases, old attics, whispering statues, haunted showboats, and invisible intruders.  I fell in love with and have always sought out stories that are Gothic in nature.  So, it should not be any surprise that I was immediately drawn to and curious about a book that looking into this very topic, even if it was focused more for girls than boys.

Gothic for Girls: Misty and British Comics
is an in-depth look at the weekly series for girls.  Author Julia Round clearly has a love for the comic, and it was heart-warming to read the story-behind-the-story that prompted this book (she remembered picking up an issue at a rummage sale, and one of the stories made such an impression on her, that she never forgot about it through the years!).  In some ways, it reminded me of my love for a TV show back in 1980 called Cliffhangers!, which ended before the last episode aired, so I never got to see how the stories ended - until more than 30 years later, when I came across a private DVD dealer who had recorded the entire show, including that final episode!  (And, interestingly enough, one of the three anthology tales on Cliffhangers! was the modern day re-telling of the story of Dracula, a Gothic character in his own right!)  After the introduction (told in comic form, which makes it even more endearing!), Round begins to methodically and carefully look at all aspects of the Misty series - from its creation to its creators, from its writing to its art, from its impact to its importance in the lives of so many young girls (and boys!) during its nearly two-year run.  Round builds up her theory regarding the comic and how it truly epitomizes a whole genre of Gothic for girls that is overlooked, and often minimized or outright ridiculed by researchers and critics alike.  And after reading this book, I have a whole new outlook when it comes to Gothic!

Round provides readers with a number of examples from the Misty comics to show just how the stories therein help define Gothic for Girls.  She looks at how the young female protagonist of these tales is usually isolated or trapped in some way ... how the stories take place in worlds that juxtapose normal reality with magic and supernatural.  She shows how "[t]he narrative is driven by simultaneous fear and attraction, generally in the form of terror, and often relating to incarceration, transformation (physical or mental), and doubt" (p 263).  She even discusses how, when more familiar Gothic archetypes are used within a story, it is normally in a subverted way (i.e., making the vampire or witch sympathetic, or even the victim of the tale).  There's no way I can say it the way she does, as Round, I think, aptly describes Gothic for Girls when she says it "constructs and acknowledges girlhood as an uncanny experience, interrogating expectations and reimagining its fears" (p. 263).

With each chapter, from the first to the last, Round builds on her definition.  It truly amazed me to realize how the actual art on the page was actually Gothic in nature - the lack of border lines, the merging of panels, the use of one panel to create a border for the next, the import of placement of panels, the careful use of shadows and color - how these various techniques help create the mystery and "otherness" that defines what most know as "Gothic."  And how the writers managed to set stories in contemporary settings with average young girls, and yet create tension and terror through what appear to be normal objects (such as mirrors, books, spiders, boxes, plants, etc.) that turn out to be something completely unexpected.  Round opened my eyes to the fact that we don't need dark castles, brooding strangers in the shadows, secret rooms, and cold, misty nights to create "Gothic" - rather, as she proves through her study of the stories in Misty, all you need is the mystery, the unseen, the grotesque, and the indescribable "otherness" to create a tale of Gothic suspense.  

While Round focuses her attention and study on developing the idea of Gothic for Girls, and how Misty plays a part in that, I would take it a step further to say that while the tales of mystery, terror, suspense, and horror within the pages of the comic all feature female protagonists and seem to deal with "female" concerns (which Round equates to the "mystery" felt by girls during puberty, when their bodies, emotions, and minds are all changing and growing), the same ideals can be applied to "male" concerns as well.  Yes, men certainly go through much different changes than women during puberty, but there are some similar things confronted by both - that sense of awkwardness, the not knowing what is to come, the uncertainty of life itself, the fear of being left behind or isolated from one's friends and family, the sudden changes in relationships with everyone around you - men feel these things just as much as women do, and all of these fears and concerns play into the "otherness" discussed by Round as being a part of the Gothic trope.  And even Round talks about the fact that Misty was not just read by girls - there were boys and men who read the comics as well (most of whom read it in secret and did not talk about it, while a few proudly stood forth and admitted their love for the comic).

I can honestly say that after reading this book, going forward, I will not be able to read anything without looking for ways in which the stories embody the Gothic, and whether, in the case of girls' series books especially, they fit within Round's definition of Gothic for Girls.  And I also have to ask this question as well - is Gothic for Girls reserved only for girls, to be understood only by girls, or can a boy read, understand, and even identify with these same fears and concerns?  Perhaps that should be an avenue of research Round should pursue next!

Now, I'm off to start my hunt for 101 issues of Misty comics!

RATING:  9 unhappy endings out of 10 for providing an entirely new outlook on a genre I already loved and providing more than enough reasons to search out the entire run of Misty!

Friday, October 21, 2022

Friday Barnes, Bitter Enemies

Well, we've reached book seven, and the never-ending troubles and mysteries that surround Friday Barnes continue, with surprises around every corner.  As you may recall (or maybe you don't, and that's why there's a "Previously in Friday Barnes..." prologue at the beginning of each book), when we last left our intrepid young sleuth, she and her friends returned to Highcrest Academy after spending a rather eventful summer vacation at camp (where they, of course, solved another mystery, this time involving an illegal mink-farming operation).  But their relief at returning to school was short-lived when they met Friday's brother and sister, Orion and Quasar.  Who were there to take Friday back home with them.  "Home" being in Switzerland, where the entire family (except Friday) were currently working and thriving in their respective scientific fields - and where Friday Barnes is about to attend a brand new school!

Author R.A. Spratt provides readers with an opportunity to see how the bonds Friday has formed with her friends, and even her enemies, at Highcrest Academy have grown over the course of the books as the new school year begins without Friday there.  Bitter Enemies opens with a rather depressed Ian and an even sadder Melanie, both of whom are unsure just what the new year is going to bring without Friday Barnes.  Even the school's Headmaster misses the young trouble-magnet, although he could certainly never admit that to anyone.  But, since this Friday's series of books, we can't exactly have a book without Friday in it - so, surprise, surprise! (or not really much of a surprise, considering how you want to look at it), Friday Barnes shows up unexpectedly, ready to start the new semester and return to her normal life at Highcrest.  The only problem is, her spot at the school has already been given away to a new student - Harrison Abotomey!  And even though the Headmaster informs her that she unenrolled and is no longer a student there, that doesn't stop Friday Barnes from moving back into the dorm with Melanie and resuming her studies  - - and crime-solving adventures!

Now, usually within each Friday Barnes book, Friday has solved a number of small (minor) mysteries along the way to solving the "big" over-arching mystery for that particular book; however, this time around, Friday's focus seems to be on uncovering who has it out for the headmasters of Highcrest Academy!   The school is preparing to dedicate a new fountain in the middle of the swamp (yeah, yeah, you have to read it to understand that one), when an accident results in one of the school's headmasters mysteriously disappearing!  Then another headmaster becomes violently ill.  Then the current one nearly has a heart attack.  Friday can see clearly that someone is determined to get even with the headmasters - but the questions are:  who and why?  And if that weren't enough to figure out, Friday also has to deal with Harrison Abotomey, who seems to be following her and Melanie everywhere they go.  Melanie is convinced Harrison is in love with Friday (why else would he be so angry with Ian all the time?  he sees Ian as competition!), but Friday does not have time to deal with a potential suitor when she's trying to save the lives of the headmasters before any more disappear.

Spratt keeps the humor that has made this series so much fun, with Friday's Sheldon-like thinking and Melanie's ever-so-lazy and clueless personality.  She also keeps that tension between Friday and Ian, with the ongoing "will they" or "won't they" tug-of-war between them.  Spratt manages to throw some great surprises and twists along the way when it comes to the mystery, which is yet another reason why reading these books is so enjoyable.  And, in case you were wondering, yes, she keeps the traditional book-ending cliffhanger - this time, Friday finds herself finally rewarded for her intelligence, analytical thinking, and well-above standard IQ - but it leaves Friday with a very important question that the reader will want to know as well - where will Friday go from here?

The final page encourages readers "To find out what happens next, read the final book in the series...Never Fear."  And the eighth book was the final book in the series - until I discovered on Amazon that book eight was, in fact, NOT the final book in the series, as there are available for purchase book nine (No Escape), book ten (Undercover), and book eleven (Last Chance).  And for that, I am eternally grateful, because Friday Barnes is just too good of a character to retire, and I hope to see her adventures continue for many years to come!

RATING:  10 identical dummy offices out of 10 for outrageously fun mysteries with a genius-level sleuth with no interpersonal skills whatsoever!

Monday, October 17, 2022

Modesty Blaise, Cartoon Adventures - Book 2 of 2: The Black Pearl and The Vikings

Time to take a trip back into the world of spies, criminals, and mysteries with Modesty Blaise!  It's been three years since I read the first of these two books, so I figured it was about time.  I rather enjoyed the first collection of these Modesty Blaise comic strips, so I went into this book with the high hopes of enjoying these tales as well - and I was not disappointed.  Peter O'Donnell proves his worth as not only an excellent writer, but an outstanding artist as well with these two (well, actually three - we'll get to that in a moment) stories collected for this second book.

The Black Pearl and The Vikings contains more than just those two stories - it opens up with a 7-page origin tale titled simply, "The Beginning," which gives readers a chance to see just who Modesty Blaise really is and where she came from.  And fair warning - there is a scene of nudity in the final panel of page three, where Modesty earns her name (rather ironically) from the old man she has been helping.  The story reveals that Modesty was a refugee child who did what was necessary to survive - and after helping an old man and traveling with him for some time, she gains a wealth of knowledge that helps her as an adult.  She ultimately meets Willie Garvin in Saigon and the two become an unstoppable team - but eventually she retires, and her enterprise known as The Network is split up among the men working for her.  It was rather refreshing to read a 7-page origin tale that gives the reader everything they need to know about Modesty and her origin without unnecessary exposition and filler material to pad it out.

And thus, we move on to the first story in this book, title "The Black Pearl."  In this story, an ancient holy man in north Bengal calls upon the aid of Modesty Blaise (who owes him for saving her life some years ago) to help recover the mysterious "Black Pearl," which is said to possess the ability to know the next High Lama.  The Buddhists must recover the ability to select their next High Lama before the men who are taking over the land misuse the "pearl" to name their own hand-picked leader.  It is clear from the get-go that the "Black Pearl" is anything but a pearl, but I was definitely not expecting what Modesty, Willie, and Mark (a former operative of Modesty's Network) found!  It turned out to be a rather fun surprise, and it allows O'Donnell to create some rather creative moments in the story as the three escape from the terrorists who have been occupying the land.  It's also interesting how O'Donnell flawlessly weaves some soap opera elements into the tale, including Mark's tale of lost love, a surprising cliff-side save, and the daring plan to escape with the "Black Pearl."  All-in-all, a really great story.

The second story is "The Vikings," which, of course, is not about real vikings (since they are long-since gone), but rather, a group of fearless thieves who traverse the waters on a boat and execute robberies of the wealthy citizens along the coast while wearing viking helmets and masks to hide their identities.  On once such robbery, however, a father recognizes his son's limp and tattoo among the thieves - so he calls on Modesty and her team to help save his son.  O'Donnell really plays up the soap opera elements in this one - the father is none-too-happy with his son's life choices, including the woman he married (who he deems "beneath" their station), the son's lingering feelings for Modesty, the leader of the Vikings' lust for revenge when Modesty bests him at his own game, the near-fatal shooting that becomes a race against time to save Modesty's life, and the son's ultimate redemption and father's ultimate change-of-heart.  Yet, despite all of these melodramatic moments, there is still plenty of action for Modesty and Willie to share along the way!

I hadn't realized it as much when I read the first collection of strips, but this one seemed to be more prominent, is the obvious fact that these were collected from comic strips.  In the two main stories, the first panel has an empty block space on the upper left corner, which must have been where the "Modesty Blaise" logo went for the daily strip, and the next two panels are full panels, and so it goes through the whole book, with the strips pretty much remaining constant at three panels per "day," with the first panel missing the block up there, and the following two panels full scenes.  And there are a couple of instances where the word balloons in one panel flowed over to the next panel - and whoever put the book together, kept the word balloon complete for the panel in which the character is speaking, but in the next panel, they left in the small portion of the balloon that carried over.  However, it was not distracting enough to take me out of the story - between the engaging story and the absolutely beautiful artwork, I don't think a bomb exploding right next to me could have taken me out of the stories while I was reading them!

I haven't been able to find any other Modesty Blaise "novels" in this format, so I'm assuming these were the only two done.  And that's a shame, as looking online, I found that the strip ran from 1963 through 2002, so there are definitely tons of stories that I have yet to read!

RATING:  10 Himalayan bears out of 10 for adventure, danger, romance, action, mystery, and so much more in fast-paced, superbly written and drawn strips!