A Rather Lovely Inheritance - first in a series of "Rather" mysteries

I came across this series because I was actually looking for a completely different series - but it just so happens that the title character in both series share the same name - Penny Nichols!  For those who don't know, Penny Nichols was a four-book series published by Goldsmith back in the 1930s, written by Mildred Wirt (Benson) under the pseudonym of Joan Clark. It featured a spunky teen detective and her private investigator father who solved mysteries, much in the vein of Nancy Drew (who first appeared at the beginning of that decade).  It apparently did not have the sales to warrant an ongoing series, and after only four books, the series ceased publication.  I have had those four books for quite a while, have read and enjoyed them all, and have never really given much thought to the actual name of the title character (i.e., the fact that her name is actually two coins - "penny" and "nickel").  Now, flash forward to this year, and while strolling through Amazon, I happened across a series of mysteries by author C.A. Belmond whose title character is named ... you guessed it ... Penny Nichols!  Not too long ago, I read a graphic novel with the same-named character (Penny Nichols), and now I found this relatively new series of novels with Penny Nichols.  So, I have to ask - why is this name suddenly becoming popular again?

A Rather Lovely Inheritance is written by an author who has experience with making documentaries, and thus, her protagonist's position as a historical researcher on documentaries of women of the past could possibly  have been drawn upon Belmond's own experiences in the film industry.  Even if that is not the case, Penny Nichols' work plays a large part of the story, and it also adds some humorous elements to an otherwise very dramatic tale.  Penny's father is the son of a war hero who married a French woman.  Penny's mother, Nancy, is from England, but she has lived in the States since she was eighteen and married Georges Nichols after she moved to New York to pursue a career in art.  Penny is named after her Great-Aunt Penelope, and it is a name she hates - after all, who names their child Penny Nichols (say it out loud and you'll understand)?  But, she's stuck with it, so she makes the best of it.

This first entry into the series of "Rather" mysteries centers around the death of Great-Aunt Penelope and her will.  It seems Penelope was very specific about her bequests and who they should go to.  Her spend-thrift nephew Rollo inherited the bank assets, while Penny's parents received Penelope's London apartment and all of its furnishings.  This seemed to cause no problems (even after learning that Penny's parents did not want the apartment and had already informed the lawyers to transfer everything into Penny's name).  However, when it came to the will governing Penelope's assets in France - well, that's another story.  Penny's cousin Jeremy inherited Penelope's villa, while Rollo inherited the contents of the villa.  Penny, on the other hand, inherited the garage attached to the villa and all the contents.  Which really did not make much sense, as Penny could not imagine anything in a garage that would be of any importance to her.  Rollo and his mother grew outraged and threatened to contest the French will, and Jeremy (who Penny had been friends with since their childhood) assured Penny they would not present any real problem.

Boy, was Jeremy wrong!

Surprisingly, the mystery here was not a murder mystery that I expected.  Instead the mystery centers around the French inheritance, a stolen photograph from the London apartment, a rare 1936 Dragonetta (which does not appear to be a real car, but one simply made up for the story - at least, from what I could find online), a missing painting, and a dark family secret that could change everything.  There's also a break-in at the London apartment, during which Penny gets nabbed and thrust into the bathroom while the thief makes his escape - a break-in that leaves Penny questioning who she can trust and whether anyone really is who they say they are!  But, just like her 1930s namesake, Penny is determined and unwilling to back down, so she sets about to uncover the truth about her great-aunt's past, her childhood friend's real family heritage, and the importance of the contents of the garage she was willed.  And by the end of the book, Penny is in for a number of surprises, all of which will definitely change her life!

The story is a very enjoyable read, and the characters extremely likable.  The cast and crew of the documentary on which Penny is working in England when she receives the call about her great-aunt's passing are all just a bit over-the-top - but not so much as to make any of them unbelievable.  Rather, they are just zany enough to give the story some humorous elements and remind the reader that not everything the world is all doom and gloom.  Erik, the set designer, and Timothy, the prop-master, are probably my two favorites of the group.  Their reaction to Penny's inheritance (and Erik's reaction to Jeremy!) are hilarious.  

Now, one last thing I have to wonder about the use of the name Penny Nichols...  I purchased the book because of the name being the same as that of Mildred Wirt's sleuth in the 1930s.  What I did not expect to find was the following passage in this book:

Actually, the name may strike you as familiar, if you were the kind of kid who liked to read children's detective stories.  Because not only did my parents give me this ridiculous name, they also took it into their heads to invent Penny Nichols, Girl Detective - a picture-book character supposedly based on me.

 

She was a spunky little sleuth who went around snooping for her friends and neighbors, solving scientific puzzles and natural phenomena as if they were murder mysteries and crimes and kidnappings, by using deduction and logic, certainly, but also memory and intuition and instinct.  She carried around a magnifying glass, and she had cooper-colored hair like mine, which she wore in pigtails.  (p. 10)

Reading this, one might wonder if perhaps Belmond actually did utilize the name "Penny Nichols" as a way to pay homage to that original 1930s crime-solving teen.  That, and the fact that in this series, Penny's mother is named "Nancy" - and it's pretty common knowledge at this point that Mildred Wirt (Benson) was the original ghostwriter who breathed life into Nancy Drew, the ultimate girl sleuth.  Sure, it could all be a coincidence, but is it really...?

I would say this book is a must-read for mystery fans, as it is a wonderful break from all the murder mysteries on the market, it introduces a wonderful new female sleuth, it is well-written, and it is truly engaging.

RATING:  10 long-forgotten unmailed letters out of 10 for giving an old-fashioned mystery name a new lease on life!