The Secret of Stonehouse - a Gothic novel for young adults

I honestly cannot tell you where I got this book or when I got this book.  I've had it for quite a while, and the only thing I know is that I picked it up some years ago because the cover had a very slight resemblance to the cover of the fifth Nancy Drew mystery, The Secret at Shadow Ranch - a young woman on a horse, looking back at a foreboding house.  It has been sitting on my shelf for years, and I finally decided it was high time I read the book.  Coincidentally enough, this book was published by Tempo Books, a division of Grosset & Dunlap, the same publisher who was publishing the Nancy Drew books back in 1973 when this book was published (the text copyright is actually 1968, meaning this is a later edition of the story).  Thus, with all of these things running around in my head, I sat down to read the story...

 

the secret of stonehouse (yes, all of the letters are lowercase in the title) tells the story of Heather Mackenna, a young girl from Scotland who has been moved by her uncle Donald around the world to live in the small town of Sky Lake, Wisconsin for reasons unknown.  As the mystery opens, Heather is pondering her fate, wondering why her uncle has moved her to such a remote location, forcing her to give up the only home she ever knew in Scotland, leave her grandmother behind, and probably hardest of all, leave her horse, Lady, behind.  It does not make sense, and her uncle Donald refuses to explain.  (We must stop a moment here and acknowledge that "uncle Donald" is not clearly defined in the beginning - Heather always refers to him simply as Donald, but he refers to himself as her father, and at a later point in the story we learn he is her uncle - her father simply dumped her off with Donald when she was but a wee lass and took off, never to be seen again!)

 

The mystery here centers around Donald's strange behavior since they arrived at Sky Lake.  He warns Heather not to tell anyone she was adopted, and more strange is his reaction to her telling him about the abandoned stone house she and a neighbor boy explored when they were riding horses (Heather makes friends with Gus, a boy whose family lives on the neighboring farm and whose horse, Cloudy, Heather has taken a liking to).  Heather is struggling to fit in, and her uncle is not making it easy.  But the story takes a darker turn when someone nearly runs Heather and Cloudy over the side of a bridge, and then someone breaks into their house when Donald is away, forcing Heather to climb out a window and run to Gus's house to seek help.  And just how does all of this tie into the story Heather has been told about the family who owned the stone house ... how the father was killed ... the baby daughter was kidnapped and later found dead, with only her clothes floating in the lake ... and the death of the mother shortly thereafter.  The caretaker still lives on the property, taking care of the house...

 

While it's not overly difficult to figure out what is going on, it's the journey of following along with Heather as she slowly puts all the pieces together.  The one thing that had me stumped was just how old is Heather?  From the start, it seemed she must be in her late teens or early twenties, as there is no mention of school, and her actions and freedom seem to indicate a young lady not long after graduation.  However, I was completely taken back when, at the beginning of Chapter 7, it says that Heather was happier than normal because "[t]omorrow was her fifteenth birthday, and her birthdays were always an occasion in the Mackenna family" (p. 84).  It was at this point that I realized this was not your typical gothic novel, and in fact, it may not have been intended to be a gothic tale at all.  Sure, it has all of the elements - a dark, foreboding house with secrets in his dark history ... a young woman terrorized by an unknown assailant ... and a man in her life that may or may not be the threat behind her troubles.  But the age of the main character derails it somewhat, and makes me wonder if the book was merely repackaged with a gothic-style cover to help sell it during the height of the gothic paperback era.

 

Regardless, the story is well-written and a good read.  Lynn Hall, in this case, is the author's real name and not a pseudonym.  She has written a number of books for young adults that feature horses and other animals.  This book appears to be one of her earlier publications, as many of her books appear to have been published in the 1970s, 1980s, and even into the 1990s. One of her books, The Mysterious Moortown Bridge (published 1980), happens to have been illustrated by Ruth Sanderson, my favorite illustrator and cover artist of the Nancy Drew Mystery Stories.

The cover art does have an artist signature of "FMA" - who, coincidentally did cover art for two Bomba, the Jungle Boy books that were reprinted by Grosset & Dunlap in the late 1970s. This would lead one to assume the artist was someone Grosset & Dunlap contracted with on a somewhat regular basis.  Some research online reveals FMA may be Francesco M. Accornero (1938-2020), who was apparently an Italian-born paperback cover artist who provided covers across many genres and was known as "Franco."  Interestingly, most of his romance cover art appears to have been signed as "Franco," so perhaps it was his earlier art that was signed under his initials of "FMA."  In any event, the cover here is definitely spooky, although it is interesting to note the variation on the gothic trope, since there is no light in any upstairs window of the house; rather, the only light appears to be coming from the partially opened front door.

While the book is definitely a young adult novel, I'd still say it's a good gothic read.

RATING:  8 cocoa-colored stuffed horses out of 10 for giving young adults a taste of the gothic genre, with the right amount of suspense and mystery!