Nancy Drew Mystery Stories # 140 - The Door-to-Door Deception

 "Nancy's on a crash course with crime!"  (cover blurb)

 

"A very good cause puts Nancy in the middle of some very bad business!" (back cover blurb)

 

It's been quite a while since I've read any of the Nancy Drew digests (those paperback books published by Simon & Schuster as a continuation of the Nancy Drew Mystery Stories started by Grosset & Dunlap back in 1930).  Over the years, I have heard many fans of Nancy Drew make disparaging remarks about the digests, claiming they lack the quality of the original series, and that the stories are nowhere near as good as "the first 56 books" (which certain die-hard fans claims are the only true Nancy Drew canon).  However, having read (thus far) books 57 through 139 (and now, with this one, 140), I can say that a number of these digests have some very well-written mysteries, some of which I would consider superior to the last five or six mysteries published by Grosset & Dunlap. However, as the series progressed, the stories did start to become more hit or miss, with some not quite hitting the mark.  This, I would have to say, is one of those.

 

The Door-to-Door Deception is not your typical Nancy Drew fare.  This is more of a story about embezzlement and burglaries.  Nancy and Bess agree to join George, who has been volunteering with a local after-school program for junior high students (called "CARING"), unaware of the trouble they will soon find themselves facing.  It seems not only does CARING have another organization, known as "YES," that is competing with them for funding from the community, but one of the counselors and one of the teenagers are not too fond of Nancy and her friends.  When some incidents take place - such as hot sauce being put into Bess's water bottle and the brake on Nancy's inline skate being tampered with - Nancy suspects that the counselor and student may be pulling such stunts to get them to stop volunteering.  When George is accused of stealing some of the organization's funds, Nancy realizes things are much more serious than she realized.

 

Meanwhile, after Nancy is stopped by the police while trying to sell energy bars to raise money for CARING, she learns from her father that there as been a string of burglaries in River Heights, all during broad daylight.  Every home had belonged to wealthy families, and somehow the alarm systems had been bypassed by the thieves.  Of course, Nancy begins to suspect that her two cases might be connected (and let's face it - when has Nancy ever had two cases in the same book that were not connected?), and soon enough all of the clues lead her to the same place.  And while one suspect is clearly involved, I will say the ghostwriter for this book gives readers a bit of surprise with the other culprit - quite frankly, it was the last person I would have suspected being involved in the whole scheme!

 

This is another one of those books that seems to place River Heights in or around Chicago, Illinois.  The CARING center is said to be located "on the South Side, across the street from Washington Park" (p. 4).  In the real world, there is a Washington Park, which is a historic neighborhood and park located on the South Side of Chicago.  Later in the book, Nancy is selling energy bars on Markham Lane (p. 26) - while there is no Markham "Lane" in Chicago that I could find, there is a Markham "Avenue."  Thus, one can assume that either the ghostwriter is from or familiar with Chicago, or specifically chose identifying places from that area to keep River Heights central to the part of Illinois.

 

Food-wise in this book, Hannah is said to have prepared a dessert she calls "raspberry fool" (p. 87), which, as it turns out, is a real thing.  A little searching online reveals it is a traditional English dessert that is easy to make - you simply stir the berries, sugar, and liqueur together and let it sit for 15 minutes; whip up some cream with powdered sugar until soft peaks form; mash the berry mixture until the liquid and fruit are mashed together; spoon half the fruit into the cream, fold once or twice with a rubber spatula, add the remaining half of the fruit, and fold again - serve in glasses with crumbled cookies on top!  (Recipe taken from:  Pioneer Woman - Raspberry Fool).  Sounds mighty tasty, I might have to try this myself!

 

Something else I learned in this book is all about the game of "newcomb," a sport which the author spends pretty much an entire chapter going over how the kids played it (pp. 45-50).  Newcomb ball is similar to volleyball, in that two teams are on either side of a net and hit the ball over the net to each other - the major difference being, in newcomb, you catch the ball and throw it back - you don't hit it back.  I had never heard of this before, and perhaps that is because newcomb is not widely played today (although it appears to still be somewhat popular in some northern New England states.

 

The cover art for this book was provided by Ernie Norcia (who provided art for 21 of the 31 covers during this particular era of Nancy Drew).  The scene is drawn from the moment where Nancy discovers, to her chagrin, that someone has tampered with her skates, and the brake part has come loose, causing her to be unable to stop herself as she speeds downhill toward a riverbank (p. 99).  For me, this cover has always appeared awkward, not really providing the reader with any idea of what the mystery is about - I mean, let's be serious for a moment: Nancy stumbling while on skates does not truly scream "embezzlement" or "burglary" at all.  The only reason I can come up with as to why the publisher chose this scene for the cover is that the book does not really have any cliffhanger moments or spooky scenes; rather, this is one of those cerebral mysteries that depends more on Nancy's analytical side than any actual physical detecting (although there is a moment where someone grabs Nancy around the neck from behind and holds her in a headlock - p. 117 - but that might have been too much for a Nancy Drew cover).

 

This was not an overly exciting mystery, was not fast-paced at all, and the introduction of little Dino (a young boy who persistently wants to help Nancy solve the mystery) is rather annoying - he sort of reminds of Midge Watson, the little detective wannabe who attaches herself to Nancy in book 73, Enemy Match.  The character is not an integral part of the mystery, but rather, is used for nothing else other than to feed Nancy clues that she could have otherwise discovered through her normal detective work.  I applaud S&S and the ghostwriter for attempting to give readers a different type of mystery (hey, it's not sabotage!), but I feel like this one simply did not read like a normal Nancy Drew mystery - no suspense, no real danger, no truly dastardly villains.  But, here we are at book 140, so I supposed with this many mysteries in the series, they can't all be winners!

 

RATING:  6 shopping bags filled with dozens of CDs out of 10 for at least trying something different and introducing readers to a tasty new dessert to try!