Whitman Mystery Stories - Tom Harmon and the Gridiron Plot

This is definitely a book I would have never imagined myself reading under any circumstances.  I am not now, nor have I ever been, a fan of professional sports or college sports.  I do not like football, basketball, baseball, or any other sport of that kind.  (I will, however, watch an ice hockey game, if I can see it live!)  That being said, reading a book about sports would never be on my radar - and yet, here we are.  In recent years, I have discovered that quite a number of the Whitman Authorized Editions actually contain some pretty solid stories, and the illustrations in some of them are actually very well done (better than many of the later line illustrations in the Nancy Drew, Bobbsey Twins, and Hardy Boys books from Grosset & Dunlap).  Thus, when I happened across this book at a local bookstore for just $4.99, and the dust jacket was in such great shape, I thought:  why not?

 

Tom Harmon and the Great Gridiron Plot was written by Jay Dender.  Who is Jay Dender, you may ask?  Well, that's a really good question, and quite frankly, I have no idea.  From everything I could find online, this appears to be the only book written by Mr. Dender, and there is nothing I could find to even indicate whether "Jay Dender" is a real person or just a pseudonym.  I found this odd, since many of the Whitman books I have read have had authors who wrote more than just one book for the company.  (There are some exceptions, where the creator of a particular comic strip character may have written the Whitman book based on their character; but that's an exception, and not a rule.)  The one thing I can say is that Mr. Dender (or whoever was using that nom de plume) was very well versed in the area of football, as the story contains quite a bit of details regarding not only how the game is played, but very specific plays and descriptions of the various plays during the games.  Only someone well versed in the game (or a super-uber-fan) would have that kind of detailed knowledge of the game!

 

The story is set at the fictional university, Stockton, where Tom Harmon is a senior and is the star player of their football team, the Panthers.  While there is a real Stockton University in New Jersey, it is doubtful, based on the descriptions in the book, that this is supposed to be that particular campus.  And while the various colleges against whom the Panthers play reflect the names of real colleges and universities in our world, Webster, Harper, Douglas and the others are also fictionally created within the story.  As the copyright page specifically indicates, with the exception of the authorized use of the name "Tom Harmon," all names and places within the story are entirely fictional.  As far as the main character goes, Tom Harmon was apparently an all-around sports star, both in high school (in Indiana) and in college (University of Michigan).  According to the brief bio of Harmon on the dust jacket flap, Harmon managed to score "33 touchdowns, kicked 33 points after touchdown, kicked two field goals for a total of 237 points - the best scoring record in Big Ten history [at that time]."   While I am unfamiliar with the man or his fame (not being a sports fan), I have no doubt he was extremely popular at the time, for Whitman to seek out and license his name for use in a book like this.  And, as it turns out, he was the father of actor Mark Harmon (who, coincidentally, played in an episode of the Hardy Boys / Nancy Drew Mysteries back in the 1970s - "The Mystery of the Solid Gold Kicker," which was about a successful football player that is framed for murder!  Coincidence?  I think not!).

 

While the main focus of the story is Stockton's goal of winning the "Big Seven" title in order to save their coach's job (his job is in jeopardy because a group of alumni were offering a rather large sum of money to the university to build additional buildings on campus - but the catch is, either the team wins the Big Seven this year, or the coach must be let go!), there are a couple of subplots that play into the story.  One is the obvious dislike that one of the players has for Tom, whether it be out of jealousy of his fame or for other reasons.  The other concerns attacks made on Tom just prior to games - the first, a physical attack when he and a fellow player are taking a shortcut through the woods; the second, an attempt to make it appear Tom cheated on an important test to have him expelled so he can no longer play for the team.  Everyone begins to wonder - is someone out to get Tom personally, or are all these tactics merely a way to keep Stockton from winning the Big Seven, so that the coach will be ousted from the university.

 

Honestly, I had to force my way through a lot of the story where the focus was on the football strategies and plays out on the field.  Dender goes into some excruciating detail that might be fun for fans of the sport, but was rather tedious for me.  The college antics of the students made for much better reading, and the tiniest bit of mystery is what kept my interest in the story.  That being said, Dender does manage to write the characters in such a way as to have you rooting for them, particularly when Tom keeps getting singled out for these attacks.  Nearly his entire team, as well as most of the students and faculty, all support Tom (as if they wouldn't, considering he is the title character, after all), and you know that, in the end, it is all going to work out for everyone - but it is the getting there that makes for enjoyable reading.  

 

The illustrator for this book is Henry E. Vallely (1881-1950), who has provided illustrations for quite a number of the Whitman Authorized Editions.   Vallely also provided illustrations for Big Little Books, women's magazines, in addition to his work for Whitman.  His illustrations are distinctive, with beautifully rendered scenes that truly stand out.  I'm always thrilled when I find a book that identifies him as the illustrator, as I know I am in for a treat with the internals.  The endpage spread is a nicely rendered scene from one of the many games played within the book, and thankfully, it does not spoil anything from the story (as some of the endpages for these Whitman books have a habit of doing).

 

While the football aspect is definitely not my cup of tea, the overall story was not bad, and I managed to make it through without getting overly bored.  A nice addition to my ever-growing Whitman collection.

 

RATING:  7 stolen brass canons out of 10 for plenty of college hi-jinks, locker room antics, and last minute winning touchdowns to craft a halfway decent story. 

 

 

A Zebra Mystery Puzzler #30 - Murder by Degrees

This book is the half-way point of the Zebra Mystery Puzzlers, as the series ended after 60 books.  The book offers up yet another new author to the series, Ann Pearson.  There are apparently a number of authors by this name, but with some research, it appears Ms. Pearson is (was?) a resident of Alabama (where this book is set), having received a PhD in English from Auburn University (which would explain why her protagonist is an English teacher at an Alabama university!).  She has authored a number of articles about local Alabama history, as well as historic preservation.  According to the sources I was able to find, the three mysteries she wrote for this series are the only three fiction novels she wrote.  Thus, her background and profession play a large part of this mystery, leaving one to wonder if perhaps Ms. Pearson was not putting herself into the story...

 

Murder by Degrees is one of those mysteries where the body is discovered within the first few pages, and the rest of the book is spent backtracking as the police, and our intrepid amateur sleuth, must sift through everything that happened the previous night in order to figure out just whodunnit.  The title is clearly a play on words, since the murder victim was the head of the English department at an Alabama university, and all the suspects are professors, some of whom have PhDs, others of whom do not.  As for the story itself - well, let's just say it surprised me.  A lot!  The writing of this book is unlike any in the series thus far.  While Maggie Courtney, a teacher at Jernigan College, is the main character and Pearson's amateur sleuth, the narrative does not stay on her; rather it seems to pivot among three characters - Maggie, of course, but also Jake Travis, the detective with the local police force, as well as Ted Meredith, a fellow teacher at the college.  There are also moments where we get snippets of some of the other characters, apart from Maggie, Jake, and Ted, and it gives the readers pause, wondering if the people we are following in the narrative could be the murderer, or if it is going to be someone from whom we do not get their point of view.  In fact, Maggie does not really take any active role in investigating until more than half-way through the book!  Her ultimately solving the puzzle is more by chance than any actual sleuthing on her part.

 

The story is also filled with a plethora of characters - and I mean a real plethora! In most mysteries, you get a few suspect, or in some instances, maybe five or six suspects.  Not in this book!  No, in this book, you get more suspects than you can possibly keep track of - and I'm not exaggerating.  The murder victim is Dr. Ruby Murdoch, Dean of Humanities and the Head of the English Department at Jernigan.  (And in case you are wondering, no, there is no real Jernigan College in Alabama.)  When Detective Travis begins his investigation, he quickly learns that Dr. Murdoch was not liked by very many people - in fact, most of the people who knew her had reason to hate her, giving them all motive for murder.  (1) Albert Cannon, assistant professor of English who is up for tenure; (2) Joe Waters is a teacher without a Ph.D. who is also up for tenure, worried that his lack of degree could hurt his chances; (3) Harriet McGraw, an assistant professor who shares a house with Maggie, who butted heads with the deceased over an art festival; (4) George Purvis, another assistant professor, about whom are a number of rumors regarding his proclivity for male students, as well as his drinking and debt problems; (5) Ronald Weir, a professor with tenure, suffering from Hodgkins' disease and a distant relative of the deceased; (6) Mrs. Boykin, a middle-aged widow who teaches only literature classes; (7) Jane Stone, the youngest instructor in the department who is reserved and keeps to herself, earning her the nickname "the Sphinx"; (8) Lorene Murphy, who is rumored to be having an affair with one of the other instructors at the college; (9) Paul Perry, the student liaison for the freshman English committee who is slick as oil and loves playing two sides against each other; and (10) Lucy, the English department's housekeeper, who seems to always be listening in or watching everything around her.  Of course, we must also remember that as far as Lt. Travis is concerned, Maggie and Ted are both suspects (but, of course, the reader can discount them, as they are both main characters, unlikely to be the culprit!).

 

Another oddity about this book are the illustrations, once again provided by Sanford Hoffman, making this the ninth book in the series illustrated by Hoffman.  The art is up to Hoffman's standard, but the scenes depicted are so bland and nondescript, one is left to wonder what possible clues could any of them hold?!  From scenes of Maggie dialing a phone with Cannon standing in the doorway, to Jane Stone sitting on the witness stand at the inquest, to three characters walking away from a shed, to a suicide note, to Lt. Travis looking at shelves of paperweights.  None of illustrations stand out as having any clues, and, quite honestly, it was not until I was reading the next to the last chapter that clues from the illustrations started to come to light - they are so subtle, so ingeniously placed, it changed my whole attitude about the book.  In fact, the clue on the cover was not at all what I thought it was; but when I realized what the real clue was, everything made perfect sense, pointing to the killer almost from the very start of the story.  For that, I have to give the author, illustrator, and publisher credit for taking what started out as a very dense, uninteresting story and turning it into quite a complicated murder mystery - one steeped in English literature.

 

Speaking of which, it should not be surprising the story is dosed with quite a bit of literature references, but one thing I did not know and learned from reading this book is that George Eliot was actually a pseudonym for a woman!  When Maggie first referred to Eliot as "her," I thought it was merely a typo.  But when Ted also refers to Eliot as "her," I looked it up and discovered that George Eliot was actually Mary Ann Evans, an English author, journalist, and poet who published her work under the Eliot pen name.  Just goes to show, you can learn something new every day!

 

What I thought was going to be the worst book in the series ultimately turned out to be one of the best, and definitely one of the most unique in writing style.  Pearson has two more books in the series, and I look forward to seeing where she takes Maggie Courtney from here.

 

RATING:  9 brand new literature book dust jackets out of 10 for a cunningly crafty murder mystery that gives readers an inside look into the lives of college instructors! 

Kristie at College a/k/a Quarry Ghost - a Milderd Benson mystery story

For many years, I have heard about Mildred Wirt Benson's novel, Quarry Ghost, which was first published back in 1959.  It is not an easy book to find (especially if you want it in good condition), and when you do find it, the prices are likely to be quite high.  I never really held out any hope of finding a copy of the book, so it sat on my "want list" for quite a few years.  Well, one of the interesting things about this book is that one year after its U.S. publication, the book was also published over in Great Britain - the only catch, it was issued under a different title!  What's even more odd is that the British title does not even give one little hint of a mystery; rather, the title under which the book was published across the pond would make one think it is simply a typical girl's college-life book!  However, when I happened across a dust-jacketed copy of the British edition for under $20, I snatched it up - and FINALLY, I was able to read Benson's last novel written for young adults...

Kristie at College is an innocuous title that gives absolutely not hint of mystery whatsoever.  In fact, the cover depicts a dark-haired girl carrying her schoolbook, while behind her other college students mingle in front of a plain brick building.  The only way one would know this was a mystery story was to read the synopsis on the inside front flap, which talks about Kristie becoming "deeply involved" in a controversy with one of the college professors and a dinosaur relic that has disappeared under his watch.  Kristie, a journalism student at Hagers College, gets the scoop from a stranger who shows up at the office of the school newspaper late one night.  He informs Kristie that he has been sent by a Canadian museum to purchase the dinosaur egg that was acquired by members of the college from an expedition in the Gobi Desert (p. 13).  Kristie takes down the information, and her story makes it to the front page of the next day's edition of the collegiate newspaper - but that's where the trouble begins!

Benson gives her readers a well-crafted mystery, where the mysterious informant disappears, the college professor who is in charge of the dinosaur egg is acting shady, and Kristie's own aspirations to be editor of the college newspaper are put at risk because of her unvetted story!  To only complicate matters, Kristie, who is on one of the school's swim teams, is invited to join a scuba-diving club who make regular trips to the local quarry to explore - but her introduction to scuba-diving and the quarry quickly escalates to a situation of extreme danger when a "ghost" seems to be haunting the place.  The ghost not only frightens some of the club members, but it also sabotages some of the students' equipment and attacks Kristie when she is under the water!  Kristie begins to realize, though, the ghost seems thoroughly focused on a portion of the quarry the students have labeled "the black hole," as it is deeper than the rest and completely dark when one swims down into it.  She soon discovers that the missing dinosaur relic, the ghost, and the black hole are all connected - and the odd, rather large man who lives in the woods outside of the quarry is a part of it all!

To any seasoned mystery reader, the solution to the conundrum is not at all hard to figure out; but it is the getting there that is all the fun.  And Benson makes it fun, because not only do we have the danger and suspense surrounding the ghost and the underwater dangers, but we get the not-so-friendly competition between Kristie and the professor's daughter, Marcia Radcliff.   After all, every good protagonist needs a nemesis to keep them on their toes!  And along the way, Kristie learns a bit about good sportsmanship, priorities, and what really matters most.  Of course, as can be expected (this is a young adult story), Kristie does end up getting the editorship, largely due to her part in finding the missing dinosaur and revealing the true criminal in the matter, and she also wins the final swimming competition, mostly due to the amount of underwater exercise she got while with the scuba club.  Thus, all's well that ends well, and as Marcia so aptly concludes the story, "With either flippers or slippers, Kristie Coleman will never be out of her depth!"

I suppose it should not be surprising that Benson would integrate her career as a journalist and her love of swimming into this tale.  As most fans are aware, Benson spent a number of years working as a journalist, which, like Kristie in the book, began in her college years working as the yearbook editor and also on The Daily Iowan, the college newspaper (Mildred Wirt Benson: College Years). In addition, while in college, Benson excelled in swimming, as well as diving, becoming a member of the "Seals Club."  According to the University of Iowa, "a photo of [Benson's] beautiful swan dive into the Iowa River is often reproduced and has become on of the Iowa Women's Archives' iconic images" (Mildred Wirt Benson: College Years).  Thus, one might wonder if perhaps Benson imprinted a part of her own life and experiences into Kristie Coleman as she was writing this book!

And apparently, Benson's daughter took after her when it came to swimming, as Benson gives a dedication of this book: "To Peggy, champion swimmer, who lost a race and launched a story."  

Personally, I prefer the Quarry Ghost title, and the cover to Quarry Ghost is much more in line with the main plot of the story.  However, I am just happy to have found a reasonably priced copy of Kristie at College, so at least I have the story to have read and enjoyed.  Maybe one day I'll come across a copy of Quarry Ghost, and I can add that to my collection - but until then, Kristie will sit upon my shelf with my other Mildred Wirt Benson mysteries!

RATING:  10 lost license plates out of 10 for a great mystery and a nice book-end for Benson's children's book writing career!